The Emo Social Club Podcast

"This record is objectively for people who were in high school between 2006 to 2008. You cannot avoid how f***ing good Martin Johnson is as a songwriter."

This week, Brian and Lizzie celebrate the nearly 20-year anniversary of Boys Like Girls' self-titled debut album. They break down the band's PureVolume and MySpace origins, Martin Johnson's undeniable songwriting chops, and why these pop-punk anthems still hold up today.  

Take a trip back to 2006 as the Emo Social Club dives into Boys Like Girls' massive self-titled debut album. Brian and Lizzie explore how four kids from Massachusetts leveraged PureVolume and MySpace to build a devoted fanbase before ever signing a record deal or hitting mainstream radio. We analyze the album's incredible staying power, from the delayed success of iconic singles like 'The Great Escape', 'Hero/Heroine', and 'Thunder', to fan-favorite deep cuts like 'Five Minutes to Midnight'. Plus, we discuss Martin Johnson’s undeniable earworm melodies, the album's sunny pop-punk production by Matt Squire, and how Boys Like Girls seamlessly bridged the gap between the emo scene and TRL pop stardom. Whether this record was the soundtrack to your high school summers or you're discovering it for the first time, join us to find out if it earns a perfect 10/10 rating.   

 

"This record is objectively for people who were in high school between 2006 to 2008."

"You cannot avoid how f***ing good Martin Johnson is as a songwriter. He knows how to write a song. He knows how to write hooks."

"They uploaded the demos to MySpace and PureVolume and quickly hit number one on the PureVolume top unsigned artist chart. By the time their self-titled debut arrived in August 2006, the audience was already there."

JOIN THE CLUB!
Youtube: https://emosocial.club/youtube
Instagram: https://emosocial.club/instagram
TikTok: https://emosocial.club/tiktok
Twitch: https://emosocialclub.tv
Discord: https://emosocial.club/discord
Facebook: https://emosocial.club/facebook
Twitter: https://emosocial.club/twitter

Support the Show:
Leave a review on Apple Podcasts/Spotify
Share this episode with a friend who needs to hear it
Support us and watch exclusive episodes: https://emosocialclub.tv
It was never just a phase. We connect the Myspace era to today's waves.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

"It's not cool to be sad. Like, there needs to be light at the end of the tunnel. And at the end of the day, we get to play something like Warped Tour. So while we are united in the fact that we all share similar experiences, you do have to still view life with optimism and know that it gets better." 

As we wrap up our coverage from this weekend at Warped DC 2026, here's a rewind to our talks with acts such as Arrows In Action, The Home Team, Huddy and more from Orlando Warped 2025.

Episode Highlights

The Home Team's R&B Infusions: The band discusses how their heavy background (prog-metal, hardcore, and deathcore) paradoxically mixes with modern R&B vocal styles to create their unique alternative sound. They emphasize their commitment to giving independent local bands openings slots on their sold-out dates.

Derek Whibley’s Walking Disaster Launch: Whibley details the origins of his new apparel and creative brand, Walking Disaster, which rolled directly following the conclusion of Sum 41. He highlights how the designs are highly collaborative, using direct fan feedback and references to past lyricism.

Girlfriends’ Nostalgic Inspiration: Travis from Girlfriends dives into the emotional weight of their record There Goes the Neighborhood, describing it as a sobering realization of growing up, acknowledging parental imperfections, and capturing youth nostalgia.

Senseless Fail & the Emo Mantle: Buddy from Senses Fail shares a candid perspective on the genre's history, claiming the band proudly carried the "emo" mantle during a time when other third and fourth-wave bands actively resisted the label.

Arrows in Action on Balance and Coping: The band details how their personal music style balances dark, brooding lyrical topics surrounding mental health with vibrant, upbeat instrumentation and dynamic live humor as a primary coping mechanism.

Oxymorons on Representation: The group highlights the massive significance of racial diversity and representation in the alternative scene, pointing out the explicit pride that fans and personnel of color express when seeing them perform on stage.

JOIN THE CLUB!
Youtube: https://emosocial.club/youtube
Instagram: https://emosocial.club/instagram
TikTok: https://emosocial.club/tiktok
Twitch: https://emosocialclub.tv
Discord: https://emosocial.club/discord
Facebook: https://emosocial.club/facebook
Twitter: https://emosocial.club/twitter

Support the Show:
Leave a review on Apple Podcasts/Spotify
Share this episode with a friend who needs to hear it
Support us and watch exclusive episodes: https://emosocialclub.tv
It was never just a phase. We connect the Myspace era to today's waves.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

"It didn't feel like I'm watching a show or I'm watching these members play these songs. It felt like I was in a one and a half hour thrill ride."  

Brian breaks down why Bring Me The Horizon's Next Gen tour is a PS1-fueled thrill ride, and the hosts discuss the scene's reaction to Beartooth's Caleb Shomo coming out as gay.

Plus, Brian and Lizzie get into the controversial new Ozzy Osbourne interactive AI avatar—is Sharon Osbourne just securing his legacy, or is this the ultimate metal cash grab? And to cap it off, they review Drake's attempts to recover from the Kendrick Lamar fallout, noting that none of his newest tracks pass the song of the summer test.

It’s another auspicious day of infotainment on idobi Radio. We’re teaching you things you didn't know, even if you wouldn't pass a college course with this info.

 

EPISODE HIGHLIGHTS:

• BMTH's Live Show Evolution: Why the Next Gen tour feels like a 90s video game fever dream.

• Caleb Shomo Comes Out: Navigating the metalcore community's response to the Beartooth frontman, and addressing lingering homophobia in the scene.

• The Ozzy AI Avatar: Debating the Osbourne family's latest IP move and the weird future of legacy acts.

• Drake Post-Kendrick: Why none of Drake's new drops are claiming the Song of the Summer title.

JOIN THE CLUB!
Youtube: https://emosocial.club/youtube
Instagram: https://emosocial.club/instagram
TikTok: https://emosocial.club/tiktok
Twitch: https://emosocialclub.tv
Discord: https://emosocial.club/discord
Facebook: https://emosocial.club/facebook
Twitter: https://emosocial.club/twitter

Support the Show:
Leave a review on Apple Podcasts/Spotify
Share this episode with a friend who needs to hear it
Support us and watch exclusive episodes: https://emosocialclub.tv
It was never just a phase. We connect the Myspace era to today's waves.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

That is JT Woodruff, the ultimate emo wife guy.

In this episode of the Make Me a Fan series, Lizzie selects five tracks from Hawthorne Heights to prove to Brian that the band is more than just early-2000s scene stereotypes. They discuss the band's history, their modern evolution, and whether Brian is ready to join the fandom.

If you had five songs to convince your friend to love your favorite band, what would you choose? In this episode of the Make Me a Fan series, Lizzie tries to convert Brian into a Hawthorne Heights believer.

Despite being in the thick of the mid-2000s scene boom, Brian originally wrote the band off as a skeptic. To prove him wrong, Lizzie brought 5 specific tracks spanning their entire discography to see if she can change his mind: "Ohio Is For Lovers," "Niki FM," "Saying Sorry," "End of the Underground," and "Cardinal."

We break down the undeniable edge-core grip of "Ohio Is For Lovers," revisit their Victory Records TRL era with "Saying Sorry," and look at their modern evolution. Plus, we talk about the nostalgia of the local scene, whether "Ohio Is For Lovers" was destined to be the soundtrack to every Matt Cutshall meme on the internet, and why frontman JT Woodruff is the ultimate "emo wife guy."

Can five songs overwrite 20 years of scene stubbornness?

 

Episode Chapters:

00:00 - The Make Me A Fan Challenge

03:15 - Breaking Down Ohio Is For Lovers & Scene Stereotypes

15:40 - Cardinal & Their Modern Sound

22:20 - Niki FM: JT Woodruff is the Ultimate Emo Wife Guy

33:10 - Saying Sorry & The Victory Records Era

44:30 - End of the Underground & Brian's Final Verdict

JOIN THE CLUB!
Youtube: https://emosocial.club/youtube
Instagram: https://emosocial.club/instagram
TikTok: https://emosocial.club/tiktok
Twitch: https://emosocialclub.tv
Discord: https://emosocial.club/discord
Facebook: https://emosocial.club/facebook
Twitter: https://emosocial.club/twitter

Support the Show:
Leave a review on Apple Podcasts/Spotify
Share this episode with a friend who needs to hear it
Support us and watch exclusive episodes: https://emosocialclub.tv
It was never just a phase. We connect the Myspace era to today's waves.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

"I would argue that Sempiternal is their re-debut album. It pivoted to something that's a little bit more poppy for the mainstream general audience... it very much was a rebranding of them in a way."

This week, Brian and Lizzie dissect Bring Me The Horizon's pivotal 2013 album, Sempiternal. They discuss the addition of Jordan Fish, Oli Sykes' shift to clean vocals, and how the band laid the blueprint for modern metalcore.  

A decade after its release, Bring Me The Horizon's Sempiternal remains a monumental record in emo history and modern metalcore. Brian and Lizzie sit down to review the album that transformed BMTH from a raw deathcore act into global rock superstars. They analyze the massive impact of Jordan Fish joining the band, bringing cinematic synths and EDM influences that completely reshaped their sonic landscape. The hosts break down Oli Sykes' evolution into clean, Linkin Park-inspired vocals and review standout tracks like 'Can You Feel My Heart', 'Shadow Moses', and 'Sleepwalking'. From the pop punk level of catchy hooks embedded in their heavy breakdowns to the nuanced electronic soundscapes that paved the way for the current 'baddiecore' movement, this episode covers it all. Did Sempiternal single-handedly save a stale scene, or are there valid critiques of its straightforward lyrics? Tune in to hear the Emo Social Club's final verdict on this definitive release.   

JOIN THE CLUB!
Youtube: https://emosocial.club/youtube
Instagram: https://emosocial.club/instagram
TikTok: https://emosocial.club/tiktok
Twitch: https://emosocialclub.tv
Discord: https://emosocial.club/discord
Facebook: https://emosocial.club/facebook
Twitter: https://emosocial.club/twitter

Support the Show:
Leave a review on Apple Podcasts/Spotify
Share this episode with a friend who needs to hear it
Support us and watch exclusive episodes: https://emosocialclub.tv
It was never just a phase. We connect the Myspace era to today's waves.

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.