History's Greatest Crimes

• Episode 8: Madame LaLaurie: New Orleans' Most Notorious Slave Owner

  Send us a textThe elegant Royal Street mansion stood as a monument to wealth and sophistication in 1830s New Orleans, its mistress celebrated for lavish parties that drew the city's elite. Behind this veneer of high society refinement lurked unspeakable cruelty that would shock even a community built on human bondage.Delving into the notorious case of Madame Delphine LaLaurie, we explore how a woman from one of New Orleans' most prestigious Creole families transformed from celebrated socialite to legendary monster. Through careful historical analysis, we trace LaLaurie's rise through three strategic marriages, her acquisition of substantial wealth, and the rumors of cruelty that circulated years before the catastrophic fire of April 10, 1834, that would expose her darkest secrets.The discovery made that day – seven enslaved people subjected to torture so extreme that newspapers struggled to describe it – provoked a level of public outrage rarely seen in antebellum America. Four thousand citizens converged on the mansion, eventually reducing it to ruins when they discovered the LaLaurie family had escaped justice. Yet this very extremity allowed the broader institution of slavery to continue unchallenged, with LaLaurie's sadism treated as an aberration rather than the logical extension of a system granting absolute power over human beings.This episode examines not just the horrors discovered in the LaLaurie mansion, but also the complex social context surrounding them – from the unique characteristics of urban slavery in New Orleans to the elaborate justifications used to defend human bondage. Join us as we peel back layers of historical romanticism to confront an uncomfortable truth: the charming French Quarter we celebrate today was built upon foundations of unacknowledged suffering, with the LaLaurie mansion standing as its most haunting reminder.Support the show

  --------  

  40:20
• Episode 7: Blood on Easter Sunday: The Colfax Massacre

  Send us a textEaster Sunday 1873 in Colfax, Louisiana became the site of one of America's deadliest acts of racial violence when a white paramilitary group led by Christopher Columbus Nash slaughtered over 150 Black Americans. Armed with rifles and even a cannon, these men attacked a courthouse where newly appointed Black officials had taken office, setting it ablaze and shooting those who attempted to escape the flames. This wasn't random violence but calculated terror designed to overthrow Reconstruction's promise of racial equality.The Colfax Massacre erupted from a powder keg of political tension. During Reconstruction (1865-1877), the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments had abolished slavery, guaranteed citizenship with equal protection, and secured voting rights for Black Americans. Yet Louisiana's disputed 1872 gubernatorial election created parallel governments, with both Republican William Kellogg and Democrat John McEnery appointing competing officials throughout the state. In Grant Parish, deliberately created with a narrow Black voting majority, this contestation proved deadly.Though nearly 100 white men were indicted for the massacre, only three were ever convicted. Even this small victory was nullified when the Supreme Court's landmark decision in United States v. Cruikshank (1876) overturned these convictions, ruling that the federal government could not prosecute individuals for violating citizens' constitutional rights. This devastating verdict effectively removed federal protection for Black Americans and gave what one historian called a "green light to terror" throughout the South.The massacre wasn't an anomaly but part of a systematic campaign of violence designed to suppress Black political participation across the former Confederacy. For nearly 150 years, a Louisiana historical marker mischaracterized the event as a "riot" that "marked the end of carpetbag misrule"—a blatant celebration of white supremacist violence. Only in 2021 was this marker removed, and in 2023, a proper memorial finally honored the victims.As descendants of both victims and perpetrators now work toward reconciliation through truth-telling, the Colfax Massacre reminds us how fragile progress can be and how vigilantly we must protect our hard-won civil rights.Support the show

  --------  

  32:44
• Episode 6: Stolen Identity: The Astonishing Tale of 16th-Century Deception

  Send us a textThe astonishing case of Martin Guerre remains one of history's most captivating instances of deception and mistaken identity. When Martin Guerre suddenly abandoned his wife Bertrande and young son in 16th century rural France, he left behind a family in limbo and a village full of questions. Eight years later, a man returns claiming to be Martin – slightly different in appearance but possessing remarkable knowledge of Martin's life, relationships, and intimate details.For four years, this man lives as Martin Guerre, resuming married life with Bertrande and fathering two more children. He reclaims Martin's inheritance and position in the community until nagging suspicions from Martin's uncle Pierre grow into public accusations of fraud and deception. What follows is an extraordinary legal battle that divides the village, with conflicting testimonies from over 150 witnesses about whether this man truly is Martin Guerre.Just when it seems the accused might prevail in his appeal to a higher court, a stranger with a wooden leg appears claiming to be the real Martin Guerre, freshly returned from military service in Spain. The courtroom drama intensifies as both men maintain their claims to Martin's identity, with Bertrande caught between them. Was she truly deceived for years, or might she have recognized the fraud but chosen to accept him regardless?The case culminates in one of history's most dramatic courtroom revelations, raising profound questions about identity, memory, and human relationships that resonate powerfully even in our modern age of digital impersonation. Join us as we unravel this centuries-old mystery that continues to challenge our understanding of how we recognize those closest to us and what it means to truly know another person.Support the show

  --------  

  40:03
• Episode 4: Bootleggers, Tommy Guns, and Bad Timing: The St. Valentine's Day Massacre

  Send us a textA Chicago garage. Seven men against a wall. The rat-tat-tat of Thompson submachine guns. By the time the smoke cleared on Valentine's Day 1929, six were dead, one was dying, and America would never view organized crime the same way again.The St. Valentine's Day Massacre stands as the bloody crescendo of Prohibition-era violence – a carefully orchestrated hit that revealed the dark underbelly of America's failed experiment with legislating morality. But why did this particular gangland execution capture public imagination and reshape national policy when so many others faded into history?Chicago's transformation provides our first clues. A booming industrial center rebuilt after devastating fire, the city attracted waves of immigrants seeking opportunity but finding discrimination. In these marginalized neighborhoods, protection rackets evolved into sophisticated criminal organizations, with Al Capone and Bugs Moran emerging as rival kings of the underworld. Their battle for control of Chicago's bootlegging empire would culminate in that blood-soaked garage, though ironically, Moran himself escaped death by simply running late.The massacre's aftermath proved equally fascinating. While widely believed responsible, Capone maintained the perfect alibi – he was in Florida with his attorneys. No one was ever convicted for the brutal killings, yet the public outrage helped cement Prohibition's failure and caught President Hoover's attention. Federal authorities, unable to pin the murders on Capone, eventually imprisoned him for tax evasion instead – a strange justice for a man responsible for countless deaths.Beyond the blood and bullets, this episode reveals how failed reform creates unexpected consequences, how violence shapes public opinion, and how sometimes the most violent criminals fall to the most mundane charges. Join us for this exploration of the crime that changed America's relationship with organized crime forever.Support the show

  --------  

  40:20
• Episode 5 - Dressed to Kill: How a Flashy Suit Sparked The Zoot Suit Riot

  Send us a textFashion isn't typically a life-threatening choice, but in the summer of 1943 Los Angeles, wearing a zoot suit could get you assaulted in the street. When military servicemen and civilians began violently stripping Mexican-American and Black youths of their distinctive wide-shouldered jackets and flowing pants, they unleashed five days of terror that exposed America's racial fault lines during World War II.We dive deep into this forgotten chapter of American history, exploring how a distinctive clothing style became both cultural armor and lightning rod for violence. The zoot suit—with its dramatic silhouette and excess fabric during wartime rationing—represented more than fashion to its wearers. For young Mexican-Americans, African-Americans, and other minority youth, it embodied cultural pride and self-expression in a society that often demanded conformity and invisibility.Through examining the buildup of tensions in wartime Los Angeles, the infamous Sleepy Lagoon murder case, and the shocking police complicity during the riots, we reveal how profoundly this "fashion crime" illuminated American prejudice. Perhaps most disturbing was the aftermath: instead of protecting victims, Los Angeles banned zoot suits entirely, effectively criminalizing cultural expression. It would take nearly 80 years for the city to formally apologize for its role in the violence.This remarkable story serves as a powerful reminder that expressions of cultural identity can become powerful acts of resistance when marginalized communities refuse to be invisible. The zoot suit's journey from symbol of rebellion to target of violence to emblem of pride offers striking parallels to ongoing struggles for representation and respect in American society. Join us for this eye-opening exploration of when clothing became crime—and how the legacy of that moment continues to resonate today.Support the show

  --------  

  24:26

More History podcasts

Trending History podcasts

About History's Greatest Crimes