The 2025 Season Begins with the Oscar Draft
Movie of the Year is back with a brand-new season, and there’s no better way to kick things off than with our first-ever Oscar Draft 2025. Hosted by Cassie, this episode sees panelists Ryan, Mike, Greg, and Taylor engage in a deadly serious competition to predict which films will dominate awards season.
Each drafter is tasked with assembling a roster of films they believe will rack up the most Academy Award nominations—across any and all categories—once Oscar morning finally arrives. It’s prediction, strategy, taste, and fortune-telling rolled into one.
The Taste Buds are back, and this time they’re playing for keeps.
Draft Rules: How the Oscar Draft 2025 Works
To ensure fairness—and maximize tension—the draft follows a snake format, meaning the order reverses each round.
Key Rules:
Drafters select movies, not individuals or categories
Any film is eligible—first half, festival darling, delayed release mystery, whatever
No two panelists can draft the same film
Five rounds total
The winning team is the one whose final slate earns the most nominations when the Academy announces them
Every pick is a bet—on the movies themselves, their campaigns, their distributors, their word of mouth, and even the voters’ unpredictable tastes.
Prediction vs Taste: Two Ways to Play
One wrinkle that defines the episode: panelists must decide what kind of drafter they want to be.
Do you swing for awards-season favorites blessed with early buzz?
Or gamble on late-breaking discoveries nobody else notices yet?
Some draft with spreadsheets and precedent. Others reach for films they want to see recognized. Every strategy has holes—and every smart pick someone else was eyeing can change the entire board.
Stakes, Tension, and Oscar Bloodsport
Unlike the usual Movie of the Year chaos, this one is deadly serious.
No bit is too small, no argument too granular, and no accusation too petty.
Ryan, Mike, Greg, and Taylor:
block each other’s picks
steal films out of sheer spite
argue over festival credibility
negotiate control of the board
and, occasionally, wonder if they’ve made a catastrophic mistake
With no immediate winner declared, the true victor won’t be revealed until Oscar nominations are announced.
Which makes the waiting—and the trash talk—that much sweeter.
Bonus Conversation: The State of the 2025 Race
Between picks, Cassie guides the panel through the critical questions that define this year’s awards landscape, including:
Are we preparing for a heavyweight Best Picture category?
Does streaming still have power?
Are studio campaign budgets shrinking—or...