399 episodes
- Do you ever feel envious about someone else’s success? Do you find it hard to swallow a loss to someone else? In this week’s episode, I want to talk about how understanding the real games you’re playing in life can help make sure you’re playing the right ones.
"It is in the character of very few men to honor without envy a friend who has prospered. " — Aeschylus
The Problem
The other day I was talking with a friend of mine that I haven’t spoken with in a few months. It was great to catch up with him and talk about all the things going on in our lives. He had some big opportunities that came up and he was telling me all about how he was capitalizing on those.
But as we were talking, I noticed something. I felt envious of what he was building in comparison to myself. I felt like what I was doing was so small and paled in what he was working on. I was happy for him, and excited about it. But there was this feeling that what I was doing just wasn’t enough.
I later sat down and wrote about how I was feeling, trying to understand why I felt that way. And really, it comes down to I want to do big things, and I feel like I’m not working as hard on creating those. I realized that’s on me, and I need to be the one to take action for myself.
I know that I’m not the only one that has felt this way. We see others being successful and wonder why we aren’t. We start to wonder if there is something that is wrong with us when others seem to be able to make things happen where we fail. While comparing ourselves to others can be helpful to understanding what it takes to succeed, we also have to be careful not let comparisons miss out on celebrating others.
The Philosophy
In thinking about my feelings around this, I realized that this type of comparison is a zero sum game. A strict definition of this is:
A zero-sum game is a situation where one person or group can win something only by causing another person or group to lose it. In other words, the total gains and losses add up to zero.
A looser definition would be:
A zero sum game is one where if someone else wins, then you lose.
There are plenty of games in life that are zero sum games. Games like chess and sports competitions only have one winner. In poker the winnings come from the players, so those that walk away with money in the pockets won it from those that leave empty handed. In resource distribution you only have finite amounts, so another person’s gain means those resources aren’t distributed to someone else. If you get a job over another candidate, you’ve won and they’ve lost.
The opposite of a zero sum game is a non-zero sum game. This is where one’s players win doesn’t necessarily mean another player’s loss. In this type of game, there is no single strategy that is always best for everyone, and the game can include cooperation and competition. In short, both can come out ahead.
Now, I need to be clear. My friend and I are not in a completion so we’re not in a zero sum game. His win doesn’t equal my loss. But I realize that we often misjudge the games that we’re playing. We think that if someone else is successful and we’re not, that somehow we’ve lost.
But there’s another theory of games that I think can broaden the scope a little better, and I think can help us view things more correctly.
In James Carse’s 1986 book called Finite and Infinite Games, he proposes that there are two main types of games in life. Finite games are one where there is an end to the game, and there is a clear winner at the end. This is similar to zero sum games.
On the other hand, infinite games have no end. The goal is to keep the game going.
When we look at games, and life, through this lens, then we can align our goals, and make sure we’re playing the right kind of game.
Politics: The Game That Has To Continue
I think a clear case where the judgments of the games are misaligned is in politics. Most political fights are played as finite games. The goal is to win the seat, the vote, the majority, and then hold it until the next election. Each side treats the other as the opponent to beat, and the rules of the game get bent in order to win.
Governing, on the other hand, is an infinite game. A country has to keep functioning through every election, every change in power, and every disagreement. The question that matters is not who won the last round but whether the institutions, budgets, and laws still work for the people living under them.
The smaller games are still real and important. Elections, negotiation, and compromise are how the larger game moves forward. But a politician who treats each vote as a final verdict forgets what the vote is for. The Stoic question is simple: does this win serve the shared work of governing, or only my side’s position in the next round?
Sometimes the answer is yes, and then losing a fight is the right move. Conceding a point, sharing credit, or passing a bill you wrote that has been amended through compromise, is a small loss that keeps the larger game alive. That is courage, not weakness.
But often we see in politics that one side will spike a good bill, obstruct institutions, or create problems in order to deny the other side a “win”. They’re playing the infinite game as if it were finite, and the country loses.
Now there are some who would disagree, and I think it’s worth bringing up. James Madison, in the Federalist Papers, argued that competing interests and ambition are features, not bugs: they check each other so no faction can dominate. A politics that stops competing could suppress dissent or let power go unchallenged.
The Stoics held that we are all citizen of a shared cosmos, with an obligation to widen our circles of concern. So the Stoic answer is not to abolish the contest but to play it with the larger game in view, so that opposition serves the country instead of only defeating the other side.
Relationships: Keeping the Game Going
We all have games in our personal lives as well, but often we misjudge the infinite game as a finite game. Most of us learn the finite game at home. We keep score in marriages, friendships, and families. “I did more of the work.” “I always call first.” “You never listen.” Each entry is a move in a finite game, and each one has a winner who leaves the other person feeling smaller.
A close relationship is an infinite game. It has no finish line. The question is not who was right in the last argument but whether the two people can still build something together.
Envy is a finite game at its most personal. A friend’s promotion, book deal, or new baby can feel like a verdict on your own life. I noticed this in myself when talking to my friend and seeing the success that he was having in his new venture. The Stoic perspective is to see that their gain takes nothing from you or your capacity to live well. Marcus Aurelius reminded himself to be careful about wanting what others had:
“Don’t set your mind on things you don’t possess…but count the blessings you actually possess and think how much you would desire them if they weren’t already yours.”
Tit-for-tat in relationships has no end state. Two people trading small slights can keep it going for years, and both feel justified. Someone has to break the cycle first. That takes courage, not weakness, and it is usually the person who cares more about the relationship than about the score.
Repair is how the game continues. An honest apology or a plain admission of fault keeps the relationship alive. Our pride treats it as a loss, but the Stoics treat it as the move that keeps the shared work going.
The Stoic concept of oikeiosis, the idea that our concern widens from self to family to humanity, starts close to home. The wider circles hold only if the small ones do. A country that cannot keep its families and friendships intact will struggle to govern itself well.
The Stoic Perspective: Playing the Game Well
Epictetus opens the Enchiridion with a clear definition of the the dichotomy of control:
“Of things some are in our power, and others are not. Our judgments, desires, and choices are ours. Votes, reputations, and other people's responses are not.”
Finite-game thinking forgets this. It chases outcomes we don't control and neglects the things we do control. Another person’s success is not yours to win or lose. You can’t control what happens to them, so viewing their success as zero-sum game is the wrong perspective.
This also helps us ground ourselves in the finite games. The election, the argument, and the rivalry are outcomes beyond us. The character we bring to them is ours, and that is where the larger game gets played. Winning a round is not the contest. Acting well inside the round, and sometimes losing it for the sake of the whole, is.
Shifting our perspective to see the larger games in key part of Stoicism. Marcus Aurelius wrote:
"That which is not good for the swarm, neither is it good for the bee,"
Losing the infinite game, at the cost of winning the finite game means that we lose overall.
Seneca also reminds us:.
“You will escape envy if you do not force yourself upon the public view.”
Envy feeds on display, comparison, and performance. The remedy is to enjoy what we have without staging it, and to stop reading another person's gain as our loss.
And Herodotus reminds us that it’s our perspective that classifies success:
"The secret of success is that it is not the absence of failure, but the absence of envy."
Politics, relationships, and envy share one question: are you playing to end the game, or to keep it going well? For the Stoics, virtue is the only true good. Winning, losing, and status are what they called indifferent, which is why conceding a small game for the sake of a larger one can be an act of virtue rather than defeat.
The Practice
So what can we do to shift our perspectives to understand the games that we’re playing and play them better?
Here’s a few steps you can put into practice:
Audit the scoreboard. When you feel a sting at someone else’s win, a friend’s praise, or a rival’s gain. Ask one question: what did I actually lose? Usually the answer is nothing I possessed, it’s just your ego feeling a little deflated. Name the scorekeeping so you can stop running it.
Separate your choices from the outcome. Before a meeting, a debate, or a hard conversation, list what is in your power (your preparation, your tone, your willingness to concede a point) and what is not (the vote, their reaction, the result). Then spend your effort only on the first list. This is the dichotomy of control applied to the game, and it works in a conversation as well as a campaign.
Play the right game. Clearly define what the larger game is. Building a better relationship, finishing a project, governing a country are very different than winning the argument, pushing your agenda, or winning an election. If winning the smaller game puts the larger one at risk it might be worth the cost.
Rehearse the loss. Use premeditatio malorum on competitive moments. Before the meeting or the argument, imagine losing the point and picture yourself staying steady and still engaged. Rehearsing makes the real loss smaller.
Celebrate the other person’s success. Practice the reverse of envy: when someone you know succeeds, say so, and mean it. Gladness is a trainable skill, and each time you practice it, the zero-sum framing loses ground.
Conclusion
We’re all playing games in our lives, even if we’re not even aware of them. By expanding our view, seeing the larger infinite games were trying to play, we can make smarter decisions, and focus on what really matters.
So back to my friend. My feelings of being smaller were mine to own. Him being successful doesn’t diminish me at all. What it really exposed is that I’ve got more work to do on realizing my own dreams, and in the meantime, celebrate what he’s working on.
The next time you find yourself in facing a loss — a job you didn’t get, an argument what you think is a zero sum finite game, take a step, and see what the real infinite game is, and keep playing.
The Build an Unbreakable Mind program for building mental discipline is now open for enrollment!
My book Stoicism 101 is available! Order here!
Find out more at https://stoic.coffee
Watch episodes on YouTube!
Find me on linkedIn, instagram, or threads.
Thanks again for listening!
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising. - The Problem
When I was in middle school, there were two brothers, Jack and Tom, who would come over to play with me and my brother. One summer day, Tom was over at our house and then Jack showed up, and he was pissed. Tom had gotten a flat and replaced his tube with one of Jack’s. Jack wanted his tube back right then, rather than waiting until Tom came home. He tried to get the tube out of the tire, but didn’t have the right tools to do it. So he got part of the tube out of the tire, then pulled out his pocket knife and cut the tube. We all stood there watching this incredulously as he stomped away.
Later that day, we walked Tom and his now un-rideable bike back to his house. There we found a frustrated Jack trying to staple the sliced tube back together. We tired for a moment, shook our heads, and walked inside.
Think about what happened there. Jack wanted his tube. It was right in front of him. And to get it back, he destroyed it.
He didn’t get his tube, and Tom didn’t get home on his bike. Nobody won. Jack wasn’t even doing something selfish, because a selfish person would have ended up with a working tube.
So what do you call that?
In 1976, an Italian economic historian named Carlo Cipolla published a short essay with an answer. It’s called The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity. It’s written with tongue firmly in cheek, but it’s one of those jokes that gets less funny the longer you think about it.
His definition is simple. A stupid person causes losses to someone else while gaining nothing, and possibly losing something too. Notice that this has nothing to do with intelligence. Cipolla doesn’t care about your grades or your IQ. He looks at what you did and who it cost.
He sorts people’s actions into four types, and we can find all four in that one bike tube.
Jack could have helped Tom patch the flat and gotten his tube back. Both of them win. Cipolla calls that intelligent.
He could have let Tom keep it and gone without. Tom wins and Jack loses. That’s what Cipolla calls helpless.
He could have taken the tube and left Tom stranded. Jack wins and Tom loses. That’s the bandit.
Or he could pull out a pocket knife. Jack and Tom both lose. That’s what Cipolla calls stupid.
And here’s where Cipolla says something surprising. He says the stupid person is more dangerous than the bandit.
That might sound wrong until you think about the tube. If Jack had been a bandit, that tube would have still existed. Somebody could have still ridden on it. A bandit moves value from one person to another. Stupidity just destroys it.
The rest of his laws follow from there.
We always underestimate how many stupid people are out there.
Stupidity shows up at the same rate in every group, whatever their education or status.
And the rest of us keep forgetting how expensive it is to be anywhere near it.
Just ask Tom, who ended up walking that day because of somebody else’s temper.
Now, this is funny when it’s a bike tube and a stapler. It stops being funny when the person holding the knife is running your company or your country. Cipolla argued that declining societies don’t have a higher percentage of stupid people. What they have is more helpless people and more of what he called “bandits with overtones of stupidity.” So this also comes down to the rest of us, and how we respond.
But Cipolla only takes us so far. He tells us what Jack did. He doesn’t tell us why.
Nobody gets up in the morning and decides to destroy the thing they want. In that moment, standing in our yard with a pocket knife, cutting that tube made sense to Jack. So what did he believe that made it make sense?
The ancient Greeks had a word for this, and it doesn’t mean stupid.
The Philosophy
That word is amathia.
It's usually translated as "ignorance," but that misses what makes it interesting. Greek has another word for ordinary ignorance: agnoia. If you've never been taught how to patch a bike tube, that's agnoia. You don't know something, but somebody can show you.
Amathia is different. Socrates saw it in Alcibiades and Pericles, two of the most highly educated men in Athens. The philosopher Massimo Pigliucci translates it as "un-wisdom," the opposite of sophia. You can be smart, informed, and capable, and still be badly wrong about what actually matters.
It’s originally a Socratic idea, and the Stoics built on it. When Marcus Aurelius prepares himself each morning to deal with difficult people, he says they're this way because of their ignorance of what is good and what is evil. He doesn't mean they're dumb. He means their values are out of order.
So let's go back to Jack.
Jack knew how bike tubes work. He knew a cut tube doesn't hold air. If you'd stopped him and asked, he could have told you that. His problem wasn't information. In that moment, he believed that being wronged was intolerable, and that making it right, immediately, mattered more than the tube itself.
That's amathia. It's why he was still standing there later with a stapler.
Epictetus has a whole discourse on this. He asks why we get angry at thieves, and his answer is that we admire the things they take. Stop overvaluing your clothes, he says, and you won't be angry at the person who steals them. Jack wasn't really fighting over a tube. He was fighting for the idea that nobody gets to take what's his.
And this is where the Stoics redraw Cipolla's chart.
Cipolla's ledger counts external things: money, status, and bike tubes. Who ends up with more stuff? But the Stoics say none of that is your real good. Your real good is your character. And that changes the math.
Take the bandit. On Cipolla's chart, the bandit wins. If Jack had taken that tube and left Tom stranded, he'd have come out ahead.
But, would he? He'd have a tube, but he'd have become the kind of person who leaves his brother stranded over a tube. Marcus Aurelius clearly reminds us: "What injures the hive injures the bee." We're social creatures, so you can't damage the community without damaging yourself.
So for a Stoic, the bandit doesn't belong in his own quadrant. He's taken a loss he can't see. Every bandit is stupid. He just hasn't calculated the real costs.
The chart changes in other places too. The helpless person loses on Cipolla's chart, but someone who willingly pays a cost to do the right thing isn't helpless at all. We'll come back to that.
And the intelligent quadrant, where your good and everyone else's line up, starts to look a lot like what the Stoics mean by virtue.
Now, it’s very satisfying to hear all of this. You could walk away thinking, "Yeah, other people have amathia. I've known so many of them."
Epictetus has a question for that person. He pictures someone furious at the fools of the world, and he asks:
"How are you suddenly converted to wisdom?"
Because what does rage at a stupid person actually accomplish? It raises your blood pressure, ruins your day, and usually makes the situation worse. It costs you, it costs them, and nobody gains.
That's Cipolla's definition.
Every one of us has a pocket knife. The Stoics aren't saying there are wise people and stupid people. Stoic philosophy holds that almost none of us are sages. We all have moments when we're sure the tube has to come out right now.
So if we can't sort the world into the wise and the stupid, and we're on the list ourselves, what do we actually do when one of these people is standing in our driveway?
The Practice
The Stoics don’t promise you can avoid the damage. Sometimes you’re Tom, and you’re walking home. What they offer is two virtues that do different jobs here. Wisdom limits how much these people can cost you. Justice decides who you become in response.
Let’s start with wisdom, and I’ll use myself as the example.
Years ago, I was living in Amsterdam and looking for an apartment, which is one of the hardest things to find. I got referred to a guy who claimed to be an agent, and he showed me a great place in a part of town I wanted to be in, at a really good price. It almost seemed too good to be true. He gave me a contract and everything.
Then came the pressure. “I don’t know how long I can hold it.” So I paid to keep it on hold, and later I paid the deposit.
Then he stopped responding to my messages. And my first thought was that I was worried something had happened to him. But when I tried to call, the number had been disconnected.
He was fine. He’d defrauded me, and that fraud is on him. But I want to look at my part, because it’s the only part I could have done anything about.
My gut told me something was off. And the two things that made me suspicious, the price and the pressure, were the same two things that made me say yes. He didn’t have to talk me out of my doubts. I already wanted the apartment, so all he had to do was threaten to take it away.
Epictetus teaches that when an impression hits you, you don’t have to go along with it right away. You can stop and test it. My impression was, “This is a rare chance, and I’m about to lose it.” The question I skipped was, “Why does this have to happen before I can see if this is legit?”
So that’s the first practice: when you’re being rushed into something you badly want, slow down. Urgency is information.
The second is to expect these people. Marcus began his day by telling himself who he was going to meet. He wasn’t being cynical. If you’re not surprised, you’re much less likely to pull out your own knife.
The third is to judge by actions. Cipolla says stupidity has nothing to do with credentials, so don’t let a title or a contract stop you from thinking for yourself. Look at what someone has actually done, and who it cost. Then limit how much they can touch. Stop having the same argument. Don’t hand them more responsibility. Let go of the idea that you’re going to win this one.
But while wisdom on its own can help you protect yourself, and help you stay out of the blast radius, it leave everyone else in it. That’s where justice comes in.
Marcus gives us the simplest instruction I know for this:
“Men exist for the sake of one another. Teach them then, or bear with them.”
First you teach them if you can. Epictetus says that if you show people their error, many will stop. When Jack was standing there with that knife, though, no one was going to teach him anything. Sometimes all you can do is bear with them.
But bearing with someone doesn’t mean leaving other people exposed. Nobody fixed Jack that day, and nobody could have. So, we walked Tom home.
So let’s go back to Amsterdam. Once I realized what had happened, I was disappointed in him and a little frustrated with myself. I resigned myself to the fact that I had made a bad choice and there was little I could do.
But there was one thing. I filed a police report. I wasn’t really doing it for the money. In fact, I had resigned myself to the idea that I would never see it. I wanted it on record, so that if he defrauded someone else, there would be a record of other incidents.
He was eventually caught. He had defrauded ten other people. And two years later, I got my money back.
I’m glad I got it back, but that’s not why the report was the right thing to do. It would have been right if I’d never seen that money again, and right if no one had ever caught him.
Remember Cipolla’s chart? Paying a cost so someone else might benefit puts you in the helpless quadrant. The Stoics call it justice.
So you have two failures to avoid. One is doing nothing while people get hurt. The other is getting even, which is how you end up holding the knife yourself.
And in between, there’s a harder path. You make sure you set the boundary. You tell the truth. Do your best to protect the people downstream. And do it without contempt, because the person in front of you is making the same kind of error you’ve made yourself. Epictetus says:
“If you must be affected by other people’s misfortunes, show them pity instead of contempt. Drop this readiness to hate and take offense.”
That doesn’t mean they get to keep doing it. It means you don’t have to carry the hatred.
Conclusion
I still think about Jack standing there with that stapler.
When I was a kid, I thought it was one the funniest thing I’d ever seen. And it is still pretty funny. But I look at it differently now.
Because there’s a moment in that story I never really considered back then. Jack had already cut the tube. He’d gotten what he wanted, which was to make the point. Then he went home, sat down with what he’d done, and tried to fix it with the only thing he could find.
I’ve done that myself. I’ve said the thing in the meeting that I had to spend the next few days walking back. I’ve sent the email I shouldn’t have. I’ve won the argument and lost what I was arguing for.
And I’d bet you’ve done it too. Most of us have a stapler somewhere.
Cipolla says we always underestimate the number of stupid people in circulation, and he’s probably right. But the Stoics would add that the count includes you, and that you’re the only one on the list you can actually do something about.
You can’t fix the Jacks of the world. You can’t control who shows up in your driveway, who gets promoted, or who gets elected. There will be people who cost you time and money and peace, and they’ll gain nothing from it. They may even leave you walking home.
Here’s what is up to you. You can see them clearly. You can limit the damage. You can look after the people standing next to you. And you can keep your own knife in your pocket.
So here’s something to try this week. Think about the situation that’s making you angriest right now. It might be a coworker, a family member, or someone on your screen.
Then ask yourself Cipolla’s question. What am I about to do, who gains from it, and who loses?
If the honest answer is that it costs them, it costs you, and nobody gains, you know what that’s called.
Put the knife away.
Then see if anyone needs a walk home.
The Build an Unbreakable Mind program for building mental discipline is now open for enrollment!
My book Stoicism 101 is available! Order here!
Find out more at https://stoic.coffee
Watch episodes on YouTube!
Find me on linkedIn, instagram, or threads.
Thanks again for listening!
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising. - Ward Farnsworth is Professor of Law and holder of the W. Page Keeton Chair at the University of Texas at Austin. He's the author of several books on philosophy including The Stoic Practice and The Socratic Method. His new book Should You Tip For Takeout? is a guide to seeing the applications of philosophy in everyday life.
Join us on this wide ranging conversation about philosophy and how you can become a better thinker! The Build an Unbreakable Mind program for building mental discipline is
now open for enrollment!
My book Stoicism 101 is available! Order here!
Find out more at https://stoic.coffee
Watch episodes on YouTube!
Find me on linkedIn, instagram, or threads.
Thanks again for listening!
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See https://pcm.adswizz.com
for information about our collection and use of personal data for
advertising. - The Problem: Living in Repair Mode
Years ago, I decided that I wanted to learn how to ride a motorcycle. They had always been scary to me and I wanted to get over that fear, and save some gas on my commutes to work. While taking the course to get my permit, I clearly remember one of the most important lessons. In order to avoid a hazard in the road — a pothole, debris on the road, a stopped car — don’t look at it. When you focus on what you’re trying to avoid, you’re more likely to ride straight into it.
There’s a name for that. It’s called target fixation. Whatever holds your eyes, your hands follow. You steer toward what you’re staring at, even when it’s the very thing you’re trying to avoid. That’s why riders get told the same thing over and over: look where you want to go, not at what you’re afraid of hitting.
I’ve been thinking about how much of our inner life works the same way.
The other day when I was journaling I noticed that I kept listing all the ways that I was falling short of the things I wanted to accomplish. All the times that I didn’t stop doing some habit that I was trying to change. In each one, I was focused on what was broken. It made me reconsider my approach.
Let me give you two people. The first is an architect. Before anything gets built, the architect has a picture of what it’s supposed to be. There’s a plan and a purpose. Every decision gets measured against that plan.
The second is a repairman. The repairman’s whole job is finding what’s wrong. Something leaks, he patches it. Something cracks, he fills it. He’s always scanning for the next problem, because that’s the job.
Now, we need repairmen. Things break, and ignoring them just makes the problem worse. But think about what it would mean to live your whole life as one, with no plan and no picture of what you’re building. Just a constant scan for what’s wrong.
I think a lot of us do exactly that when it comes to who we are.
Try this. Think about the things you’re trying to improve about yourself right now. If you’re like most people, the list sounds something like: stop yelling, stop procrastinating, stop scrolling, stop overthinking, fix my temper.
Notice something about that list. Every item is a pothole. It’s a list of what’s broken.
And underneath that list there’s usually a quieter belief. It goes something like: once I fix all of this, then I’ll be a good person, as if goodness is what’s left over after you’ve patched every leak.
Here’s what happens when you live that way.
First, the flaw becomes the center of your attention. You wake up thinking about it and you go to bed reviewing it. You’re staring at the pothole, and you know where that leads.
Second, you become reactive. If there’s no plan, the only thing that tells you what needs attention is whatever feels uncomfortable right now. Today it’s your temper, tomorrow it’s your phone, next week it’s something else. You’re always responding and never building.
And third, the one that does the most damage: you start to believe the repairman’s basic assumption, which is that something is broken. Not that something went wrong, but that I am broken. Your identity becomes the defect list.
Picture two homeowners. Over the course of a year, they spend exactly the same amount of money on their houses. The first one only calls someone when something breaks. A leak here, a cracked tile there. All year long he’s fixing. The second one has a plan. He’s finishing the basement. When a pipe leaks along the way, he fixes it too, but the repair serves the plan.
At the end of the year, the first homeowner has the same house he started with. The second one has a better one.
So here’s where I want to land with this idea. Repair isn’t the problem. We all have things to fix, and pretending otherwise is just another way of avoiding things. The problem is repair without a blueprint. Because without a picture of what you’re building, you can’t even tell what’s actually broken. You only know what hurts.
And the Stoics had a lot to say about that.
The Philosophy: You Need a Blueprint
Start with a simple question. What does it mean for something to be broken?
A chair with a cracked leg is broken because it can’t do what a chair is for, which is holding you up. A clock that won’t keep time is broken because keeping time is its job. “Broken” always means broken relative to a purpose. Without knowing what something is for, you can’t say whether it’s broken. You can only say whether you like it.
The same goes for us. If you don’t know what you’re for, you have no way to tell a real flaw from something that’s just uncomfortable.
Marcus Aurelius wrestled with this on mornings when he didn’t want to get out of bed. In the first entry of Book Five of the Meditations, he reminds himself:
“In the morning when thou risest unwillingly, let this thought be present — I am rising to the work of a human being. Why then am I dissatisfied if I am going to do the things for which I exist and for which I was brought into the world? Or have I been made for this, to lie in the bed-clothes and keep myself warm?”
Notice what he does there. He doesn’t attack himself for being lazy. He doesn’t make a list of his flaws. He asks what he was made for, and he measures the moment against that. That’s an architect’s question.
Seneca gave his friend Lucilius a very practical version of this. In his Letters to Lucilius, he tells Lucilius:
“Cherish some man of high character, and keep him ever before your eyes, living as if he were watching you, and ordering all your actions as if he beheld them.”
He then gives him a few examples to follow:
“Choose therefore a Cato; or, if Cato seems too severe a model, choose some Laelius, a gentler spirit.”
And then he gives the reason, which I love.
“For we must indeed have someone according to whom we may regulate our characters; you can never straighten that which is crooked unless you use a ruler.”
That’s the blueprint. And notice that the role model isn’t there to shame you. It’s there to show you what “straight”, what good character, actually looks like.
Epictetus says the same thing in the Enchiridion.
“Immediately prescribe some character and some form to yourself, which you shall observe both when you are alone and when you meet with men.”
Decide who you are going to be, and then build to that.
Now, I want to be honest here, because there’s a fair objection. The Stoics did a lot of repair work. Epictetus called his school a hospital. He said you shouldn’t walk out of a philosopher’s lecture feeling pleased with yourself, but feeling the sting of treatment. Seneca describes reviewing his entire day every night once the lamp was out:
“What bad habit of yours have you cured to-day? what vice have you checked? in what respect are you better?”
So weren’t the Stoics repairmen?
Look closer at Seneca’s review. He asks what bad habit he cured that day and what fault he resisted. But he also asks in what way he’s better. That’s not just hunting for defects. That’s checking progress against a plan. The inspection only makes sense because he knows what he’s trying to build.
That’s the difference. The Stoics repaired, but always against a blueprint.
And there’s something else in Stoicism that should take a lot of pressure off. The Stoics held that everyone who isn’t a perfect sage is, in an important sense, equally short of virtue. Cicero used the image of a person drowning a few inches below the surface can’t breathe any better than one drowning at the bottom of the sea.
That sounds rough, but let’s think about about what he really meant. If the gap between you and perfect virtue doesn’t close until you’re a sage, then “I’ll fix everything first, and then I’ll be good” is literally impossible. You’ll never finish the repairs.
So the Stoics stopped measuring the gap. They measured direction. They had a name for the person who is facing the right way and moving, the prokoptōn, someone making progress. Not finished. Not perfect. Someone under construction.
So how does building actually work?
Epictetus describes it clearly:
“If you like doing something, do it regularly; if you don't like doing something, make a habit of doing something different. The same goes for moral inclinations. When you get angry, you should know that you aren't guilty of an isolated lapse, you've encouraged a trend and thrown fuel on the fire.”
Then he applies it to anger.
“If you don't want to be cantankerous, don't feed your temper, or multiply incidents of anger. Suppress the first impulse to be angry, then begin to count the days on which you don't get mad.”
That’s not a repairman fighting a flaw head-on. That’s a builder killing one habit while building another.
Let me make that real.
Picture a dad who keeps snapping at his kids. In repair mode, his project is “stop snapping at my kids.” Every night he replays the moments he lost it. He feels terrible. He resolves to do better. And snapping at his kids stays the center of his attention. It’s the pothole he can’t stop staring at.
Now give him a blueprint. Instead of “stop snapping,” he asks: “What kind of father do I want to be?” Maybe the answer is: I want to be the dad my kids aren’t afraid to bring bad news to.
Now he has something to build. When they come to him, he gets down at eye level. He asks a question before he reacts. He lets a pause happen. He’s building a new way of being.
And here’s the thing. He didn’t defeat the snapping. He crowded it out. There’s less room for it, because he’s filling that space with something else. Rater than being a broken father being repaired, he’s a father under construction.
The Practice: From Stop List to Blueprint
So what do you actually do with this? Here’s a practice in four steps. You can do the first three in about fifteen minutes, and the fourth takes a few minutes every night.
Step one: write your stop list.
Get a piece of paper and write down the things you’re trying to fix about yourself.
A few that I had on my list:
Stop scrolling on social media when you get up in the morning.
Stop pushing things off just because you’re tired.
Don’t have a whiskey with dinner on weekdays.
Then look at the list. Count how many items start with “stop,” “less,” “don’t,” or “fix.” If it’s most of them, you’re not alone.
Psychologists call these avoidance goals: goals aimed at getting away from something rather than moving toward something. In a 1997 study, Andrew Elliot, Kennon Sheldon, and Marsha Church followed students across a semester. The students who had more avoidance goals reported lower well-being, and their well-being actually declined over the semester. Your stop list is just a list of potholes. Staring at it wears you down.
Step two: turn each item into a blueprint.
For every item on the list, ask yourself: If this flaw weren’t here, what would be standing in its place? Who would I be?
“Stop procrastinating” becomes “someone who starts before he feels ready.”
“Less time on my phone” becomes “someone who is actually present with the people in front of him.”
“Stop snapping at my kids” becomes “the dad my kids aren’t afraid to bring bad news to.”
Here’s a quick test. Could you say the new version about the person you’d choose as your Cato? If you can, it’s a blueprint. If it still sounds like a correction, keep working on it.
This is Seneca’s ruler. You’re not writing a list of what’s crooked anymore. You’re drawing what straight looks like.
Step three: attach one small action to each blueprint.
Remember Epictetus: every habit is strengthened by the corresponding acts. So for each line on your blueprint, pick one small, concrete action you can do today:
Starts before you feels ready mean working on the first ten minutes of the hardest task, before getting stuck clearing email.
Being present with the people in front of you means putting phone in another room during dinner.
The dad his kids can talk to starts with one question before reacting.
Keep each action small enough that you can do it on a bad day. Construction doesn’t happen in heroic bursts. It happens one brick at a time.
Step four: change your evening review.
Keep Seneca’s practice, but notice where you point it. Instead of starting with “What did I do wrong today?”, ask two questions:
Where did I build today?
Where did I drift from the plan?
Notice the word drift. Not “fail” and not “break.” When a cyclist drifts off his line, he doesn’t decide he’s a terrible rider. He looks up and steers back. Drift is a navigation problem, not a verdict on your character.
And then do what Epictetus suggested: count the days. Not the days you failed, but the days you built. Once a week, look back at the count. That’s how you see your trajectory, which is the only thing a prokoptōn is measuring.
One warning. Don’t let the blueprint become a new stick to beat yourself with. If you catch yourself holding it up and thinking “look how far I am from that,” you’re measuring the gap again. You’ve turned the architect back into a repairman. The blueprint points a direction, not distance.
Which brings us to what to do when you drift, and you will.
Conclusion: Maintenance not Repair
Let's go back to the house one more time.
The architect's house still needs work. Gutters get cleaned. Paint gets touched up. The furnace gets serviced every fall. From the outside, it looks a lot like what the repairman does.
But it isn't the same. Repair is triggered by failure. Something breaks, it hurts, and you scramble to fix it. Maintenance is done before anything breaks, and for a completely different reason. You maintain something because it's worth keeping.
I make sure to make time for maintenance on my bike. Cleaning the chain, checking the tires before a long ride. I don't do it because the bike is broken. I do it because you care about my bike and where it's going to take me.
That's the shift I want to leave you with. The same work can come from two completely different places. You can work on yourself because you believe you're broken, or because you believe you're building something worth taking care of.
Maintenance assumes you've already built something of value. And you have. Every time you acted on your blueprint, every brick you laid, that's real. It's yours. Taking care of it isn't an admission that you're broken. It's what you do with something you value.
And you will drift. Some days you'll snap at your kids. Some days the phone will win. Marcus Aurelius knew this. He was emperor of Rome, writing to himself, and he still needed this reminder:
"Be not disgusted, nor discouraged, nor dissatisfied, if thou dost not succeed in doing everything according to right principles; but when thou hast failed, return back again, and be content if the greater part of what thou doest is consistent with man's nature, and love this to which thou returnest."
Return back again. Not "start over," and not "tear it all down." Return to the plan. And notice the last part: love this to which thou returnest. He's not telling himself to grit his teeth and go back to the work. He's telling himself to love the blueprint. To love what he's building.
That's the difference between a repairman and an architect. One works out of fear of what's broken. The other works out of love for what's being built.
So here's what I'd ask you to take with you this week. You don't become good by fixing everything that's wrong with you. You'll never finish that list. You become good by building what's right, and the fixing takes care of itself along the way.
Pick your Cato. Draw your blueprint. Lay one brick today.
And when you're out there, on the bike or anywhere else, and you notice your eyes locking onto the pothole, remember what every rider learns:
Look where you want to go.
The Build an Unbreakable Mind program for building mental discipline is now open for enrollment!
My book Stoicism 101 is available! Order here!
Find out more at https://stoic.coffee
Watch episodes on YouTube!
Find me on linkedIn, instagram, or threads.
Thanks again for listening!
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising. - Find the transcript here.
The Build an Unbreakable Mind program for building mental discipline is now open for enrollment!
My book Stoicism 101 is available! Order here!
Find out more at https://stoic.coffee
Watch episodes on YouTube!
Find me on linkedIn, instagram, or threads.
Thanks again for listening!
Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.
More Education podcasts
Trending Education podcasts
About Stoic Coffee Break
"Act on your principles, not your moods." A weekly meditation on how Stoic principles can help you be a better human. https://stoic.coffee
Follow us on social media:
https://instagram.com/stoic.coffee
Podcast websiteListen to Stoic Coffee Break, On Healing and many other podcasts from around the world with the radio.net app

Get the free radio.net app
- Stations and podcasts to bookmark
- Stream via Wi-Fi or Bluetooth
- Supports Carplay & Android Auto
- Many other app features





































