Anseo.net - If I were the Minister for Education

In this episode of If I Were the Minister for Education, I explore how behaviour support in Irish primary schools has shifted from corporal punishment to rewards and consequences, and now toward restorative practice, nurture spaces, and Collaborative & Proactive Solutions (CPS). I’m joined by Dr. Ross Greene, founder of Lives in the Balance and author of The Explosive Child, Lost at School, and The Kids Who Aren’t OK, and by Ruth Edie, principal in Dublin 18 and a certified CPS trainer. We discuss CPS’s focus on solving the unsolved problems behind concerning behaviour through proactive, collaborative Plan B conversations, including the ASEP process and practical “drilling” strategies. We also compare CPS with restorative practice, address concerns about time and “letting kids off,” and share resources (livesinthebalance.org/ireland). I dedicate the episode to my late deputy principal Emer and HSE psychologist Toby.
00:00 Welcome and Overview
00:39 Behavior Shifts in Schools
01:59 Discovering CPS
03:10 Dedication and Intro
03:48 Meet Ross and Ruth
05:18 Ross Green Background
06:26 Ruth Eadie Journey
10:05 What Is CPS
13:14 ASEP and Unsolved Problems
15:06 Plan B Conversation
19:47 Drilling Strategies
21:09 When CPS Starts
22:49 Handling I Don’t Know
24:33 Ireland Context Setup
25:17 Piloting CPS in Ireland
25:50 Tribute to Toby and Emer
27:12 Restorative Practice vs CPS
29:16 What CPS Adds for Teachers
30:18 Finding Time for CPS
32:48 Common Pushback and Myths
35:56 Where to Learn CPS
38:05 Minister for a Day
41:48 Final Resources and Farewell


This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonmlewis.substack.com/subscribe

Deirdre O’Toole is one of Ireland’s best known educators. She started her well-known Instagram page in 2018 - the Playful Classroom, which explored early infant education - but had since become heavily involved in teaching and learning reading. She took it upon herself to bring the Right to Read conference to Ireland and this will take place next weekend, 21st March 2026. All 400 tickets sold out in under 90 minutes.
Deirdre and I have never met in real life (that’s going to happen at the INTO Congress this year) but we first came across each other over 20 years ago on the Education Posts Forum, where many teachers of our vintage got their first taste of online discussions.
You can find Dee on Instagram, LinkedIn and Facebook and keep an eye out for resources from the Right to Read Conference.


This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonmlewis.substack.com/subscribe

In this episode of If I were the Minister for Education, I break down what happened after projected SNA allocations for the 2026/27 school year showed roughly 200 schools set to lose at least one Special Needs Assistant: not due to cuts or clerical error, but because of how the national redistribution model works under a capped total.
I explain the background to the current situation, including the long period where schools largely held on to allocations since around 2017, the return of NCSE-led reviews from 2023 onward, and how this year’s broader round of reviews led to some schools being told they had more SNAs than the model allowed.
I talk through the predictable political cycle that followed: schools and parents mobilised, pressure built, the Minister “paused” the process, additional funding was announced (€19 million), and the government confirmed no school would lose an SNA this year. While I’m relieved for schools, principals and SNAs facing uncertainty, I argue that pausing-and-funding responses don’t fix the underlying pattern and that we’re likely to repeat the same crisis again.
I also say I feel sorry for the NCSE in this instance because they became the visible face of a policy they were implementing, and I argue the real issue sits higher up the chain. I then outline what I see as the structural problem: Ireland’s primary schools are publicly funded but privately managed individual entities competing for enrolment, staff and survival, while staffing supports (SNA posts and SET hours) are allocated through a national, projection-based redistribution model. I describe how redistribution creates concentrated losers and dispersed winners, making it politically fragile, and I connect this to the annual “cluster games” around SET allocations.
Finally, I set out the kind of structural change I think is needed: moving away from competition as the organising principle by exploring regional employment and local coordination through education authorities, because I don’t believe repeated annual firefighting counts as planning. I also reference additional writing and commentary, including an Irish Independent piece by Fionnan Sheahan and analysis by Ciara Reilly, and I point listeners toward my Substack articles for more.
00:00 Welcome and Subscribe
00:47 SNA Allocations Fallout
02:30 How the SNA Model Works
04:28 From Freeze to Reviews
07:59 Backlash and the Pause
09:11 Predictable Crisis Cycle
10:03 Relief and Real Stakes
12:19 Why NCSE Took the Heat
14:06 Schools Compete to Survive
17:09 Redistribution vs Competition
18:25 SET Cluster Games Parallel
22:42 Politics and Concentrated Anger
29:29 What Would Actually Change
33:16 Final Thoughts and Goodbye


This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonmlewis.substack.com/subscribe

In this episode of ‘If I Were the Minister for Education,’ I discuss the tumultuous journey of the Irish Primary Language Curriculum since its inception in 2016. I explain the confusing and unworkable nature of the curriculum, which stemmed from panic-induced reforms after a minor dip in Ireland’s PISA scores in 2009. I highlight the chaotic development process plagued by bullying allegations and mass resignations within the NCCA. I describe the practical challenges teachers faced with the original curriculum’s complex and unmanageable format, likening it to an accordion. Despite efforts by the PDST to provide clarity, the curriculum remains inadequately understood and halfway implemented a decade later. I underscore the recurring patterns of vagueness and panic-driven educational reforms in Ireland, leaving teachers to navigate and adapt to these changes on their own.
00:00 Introduction to the Podcast
00:47 The Primary Language Curriculum: A Decade of Confusion
02:15 The Roots of the Curriculum Chaos
05:07 The PISA Panic and Its Aftermath
09:56 The Chaotic Development Process
15:13 The Unmanageable Curriculum Rollout
21:13 Teachers’ Struggles and Adaptations
23:55 Reflections and Future Concerns
27:08 Conclusion and Farewell


This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonmlewis.substack.com/subscribe

I couldn’t think of a better title to this week’s podcast which is all about admin work. Unfortunately, the biggest change to my job in the last decade or two is the crazy increase in administrative work and constant additions to my workload. My brain physically can’t hold it all so I decided to make it my aim to outsource my brain. This episode goes through some techy tools to help with admin. If nothing else, it will make a good sleeping aid.


This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit simonmlewis.substack.com/subscribe