How Social Media Broke Fashion (and Everything Else) with Taylor Lorenz
Tech journalist and creator @TaylorLorenz joins Amy Odell on the Back Row podcast to explain how social media has completely reshaped fashion. From the backlash against fashion creators to why facts barely matter online, they dive into Vogue World, The Row's viral sample sale, and more.
Taylor, formerly at The Atlantic, The New York Times, and The Washington Post, now runs her own newsletter, podcast, and YouTube channel covering the creator economy.
Chapters:
00:00 – Intro: Amy Odell welcomes Taylor Lorenz
00:53 – Why fashion people are frustrated with social media
01:49 – Why audiences trust creators more than experts
02:42 – How algorithms reward outrage
03:36 – Why being first beats being accurate
04:25 – “Facts don’t matter”: the validation economy
05:55 – Platforms secretly boost and suppress creators
06:41 – Why follower count no longer matters
07:29 – The death of critics (and why creators can’t be honest)
08:15 – Will AI actually help creators?
11:40 – How creators really make money in 2025
12:38 – Advent calendars, meme marketing, and virality
14:23 – The Row sample sale goes viral
16:55 – Can fashion brands control their image? (No.)
18:36 – The famous "Open letter to The Row"
19:32 – Brands vs creators: a toxic relationship
20:20 – Why brands can’t stop creators from posting
22:05 – Why chasing access will break your heart
22:49 – Anna Wintour’s decline and cultural relevance
25:08 – Vogue World and the struggle for relevance
26:41 – The Met Gala red carpet isn’t what it used to be
29:46 – The Devil Wears Prada prequel problem
30:38 – What it takes to survive online long-term
32:13 – Why Becca Bloom fascinates people
33:15 – The obsession with “capitalism slop”
34:07 – Hustle culture and the fantasy of success
Links & Resources:
Back Row newsletter
https://amyodell.substack.com
Amy Odell Instagram
https://www.instagram.com/instamyodell/
Taylor Lorenz
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@TaylorLorenz
User Mag (Newsletter): https://www.usermag.co/
Power User (Podcast): https://open.spotify.com/show/5iganPXXEoTDB9lIQzY7Fh
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/taylor-lorenzs-power-user/id1733535260
Creators / links mentioned
"Open Letter to The Row" (Neelam Noted): https://neelamahooja.substack.com/p/open-letter-to-the-row-we-need-to
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
--------
34:53
--------
34:53
What Fashion's Wealthy 'Very Important Clients' Want and Gift for the Holidays
"Hermès playing cards are my go-to."
Chapters:
01:35 - VIC no. 1: The Expat Living in Dubai
03:10 - VIC no. 2: The Personal Shopper for Upper East Siders
03:32 - VIC no. 3: The expat living in Hong Kong
05:31 - VIC no. 4: The New Yorker who's feeling uninspired
06:42 - VIC no. 5: The Personal Stylist to Upper East Side Billionaires and Centi-Millionaires
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
--------
9:26
--------
9:26
Is Vogue Still Relevant? Rachel Tashjian on Fashion’s Power Shift
Fashion critic Rachel Tashjian joins Amy Odell to unpack the biggest shifts happening right now in fashion media. From Vogue’s future to the creator vs. critic debate, AI-generated fashion models, $26,000 Versace dresses, and why fashion discourse seems to be getting meaner.
Rachel, formerly the Fashion Critic at the Washington Post and now Senior Style Reporter for CNN, breaks down:
Chapters:
00:00 – Intro: Amy Odell welcomes Rachel Tashjian
00:21 – Rachel’s new role at CNN
02:34 – Why video matters in fashion journalism
03:54 – Are people still reading? Changing media habits
04:22 – Amy on books, audiobooks, and audience shifts
05:49 – The rising tension in fashion discourse online
07:16 – When commentary overshadows the clothes
08:22 – Algorithms flatten expertise in fashion
09:29 – Creators vs. traditional editors: a 15-year evolution
10:43 – Substack, TikTok, and where fashion criticism lives now
11:35 – Access, honesty, and the cost of true criticism
12:46 – Do creators need editors? The “no safety net” problem
13:19 – Dior controversy: when brands exclude influencers
14:31 – Should influencers follow critic standards?
15:35 – Does Vogue still matter in 2025?
17:06 – Why Vogue covers still trigger huge reactions
18:33 – Anna Wintour’s influence across culture
19:32 – How AI is about to transform fashion media
20:55 – Performative fashion vs. post-Instagram design
22:33 – Can AI replace fashion creators?
23:54 – AI’s role in fashion advertising and image-making
24:43 – Will AI replace human fashion voices?
25:31 – The future: will Vogue become just covers?
27:14 – The price conundrum: $26,000 dresses and who they’re for
28:55 – What fashion brands really want from the public
30:49 – TikTok’s misinformation problem in fashion
31:49 – The Vogue rumor and how fake fashion news spreads
31:57 – Three fashion creators Rachel loves
33:29 – Three fashion creators Amy loves
Links & resources:
Back Row newsletter
https://amyodell.substack.com
Amy Odell Instagram
https://www.instagram.com/instamyodell/
Rachel Tashjian
CNN announcement: https://cnnpressroom.blogs.cnn.com/2025/10/07/rachel-tashjian-joins-cnn-as-senior-style-reporter/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theprophetpizza/
Creators mentioned
Kim Russell @TheKimbino: https://www.instagram.com/thekimbino/
Jay Tibbits: https://www.instagram.com/jaytibbitts/
Rashida Renée @:howtobeafuckinglady: https://www.instagram.com/howtobeafuckinglady/
Mandy Lee @OldLoserinBrooklyn: https://www.instagram.com/oldloserinbrooklyn/
Timothy Chernyaev @relaxitsonlyfashion on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@relaxitsonlyfashion?lang=en
Fashion Roadman: https://www.youtube.com/@FashionRoadman/videos
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
--------
34:14
--------
34:14
The Devil Wears Prada: Anna Wintour and the Assistant Who Started It All
And a bunch of other pieces from her clothing line. This is my story. Check out the photos in the Back Row story.
2:16 - Trying the gray T-shirt and jeans
4:23 - Trying the legendary black pants
5:10 - The oversized gray suit
6:13 - The Blair midi dress (one with the rouching)
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices