This week on Cryptid Cocktail Party, we're diving butthole first into one of the most unsettling paranormal mysteries out there...Cattle Mutilation. TRIGGER WARNING: LOTS OF DEAD ANIMAL TALK. Seriously, it gets pretty gnarly. We break down where it all began, how it got roped in with UFOs, government experiments, and the satanic panic plus some of the more bizarre modern cases. Is it predators? Aliens? Cults? Well, you're just gonna have to listen and find out I guess.
All You Can Eat Creepypasta Part 2 (feat. Scared All The Time, Believing The Bizarre, and What About Weird?)
11/05/2026 | 52 mins.
Part two has arrived! This week you're gonna hear stories from Chris and Ed from Scared All The Time as well as Tyler and Charlie from Believing The Bizarre and just like last weeks...its a great time. Enjoy!
All You Can Eat Creepypasta Part 1 (feat. Scared All The Time, Believing The Bizarre, and What About Weird?)
06/05/2026 | 1h 2 mins.
Its our three year anniversary guys!
To celebrate this momentous occasion, we thought it would be fun to get some of the old podcast homies together and read some creepypastas to each other and man was it a good idea. The vibes were great, the jokes were on point and the pastas were creepy. So sit back, grab a fork, and enjoy!
This weeks stories are read by yours truly and What About Weird? And in part two you'll here from the Scared All The Time and Believing The Bizarre boys so make sure to come back. Please.
The Dover Demon (Redux)
27/04/2026 | 30 mins.
This week, we revisit one of the earliest episodes Cryptid Cocktail Party episodes and finally introduce Sarge to the weird, hairless, big-eyed nightmare known as the Dover Demon!
Over the course of a single weekend in 1977, multiple witnesses reported seeing the same thing: a pale, spindly creature with glowing eyes and a head that is WAY too big for its body. So what the hell was it? A misidentified animal? A hoax? Something not of this world? Well...
Crack a beer and lets dive in!
The Max Headroom Incident
20/04/2026 | 34 mins.
Welcome back to another episode of Cryptid Cocktail Party! This week we are diving into one of the most infamous incidents in television broadcasting history...the Max Headroom Incident. In 1987 a man hijacked live broadcasts in Chicago wearing a Max Headroom mask, acted like an absolute menace, AND got away with it. Its a wild story so be sure to sit back, strap in, and enjoy. And be sure to call or text our hotline! Tell us your stories, text us photos and videos of evidence, or leave us a brief message or two by simply calling or texting 321-300-5606