7 episodes
- Episode 6 — Aguadilla: What Does the Video Actually Prove?
On April 25, 2013, a federal surveillance aircraft near Aguadilla, Puerto Rico, recorded something unusual through its infrared camera.
The footage appears to show an object moving at extraordinary speed, disappearing into the ocean, and seemingly splitting into two.
But what does the evidence actually prove?
In this episode of Evidentiary, investigative journalist Lew Austin Hastings examines one of the most debated UAP recordings of the modern era.
The Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies (SCU) published an investigation suggesting extraordinary flight characteristics. Years later, the Pentagon's All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO) reached a very different conclusion.
We examine both investigations and introduce findings from Evidentiary's independent forensic analysis.
INSIDE THE INVESTIGATION
The missing distance measurement and why it matters when calculating speed.
Camera geometry, aircraft movement, and parallax.
Infrared contrast changes and their possible explanations.
Radar records and the challenge of matching aircraft positions to video timestamps.
Whether the object actually entered the ocean.
Whether one physical object truly separated into two.
What SCU, AARO, and our independent findings establish.
OUR ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Evidentiary examined camera-overlay coordinates, line-of-sight geometry, and candidate radar-track data.
Our findings highlight an important distinction: camera-displayed target coordinates may represent a calculated ground intersection rather than the object's actual location.
We also identified a preliminary timing adjustment that improved the alignment of a candidate aircraft radar track with video-derived positions. This remains an analytical result, not a verified clock correction.
Neither finding independently establishes extraordinary speed, underwater travel, or physical object splitting.
ARCHIVAL AUDIO
Robert Powell — Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies. Commentary on apparent object splitting and transmedium behavior.
Dr. Jon Kosloski — Director, AARO. Excerpt from a congressional oversight hearing.
PRIMARY SOURCES
SCU — Aguadilla Incident Report:
https://www.explorescu.org/post/2013-aguadilla-puerto-rico-uap-incident-report-a-detailed-analysis
AARO — Puerto Rico Case Resolution:
https://www.aaro.mil/Portals/136/PDFs/case_resolution_reports/AARO_Puerto_Rico_UAP_Case_Resolution.pdf
C-SPAN — AARO Congressional Hearing:
https://www.c-span.org/program/senate-committee/oversight-hearing-on-all-domain-anomaly-resolution-office-and-uaps-ufos/652316
3AF/SIGMA2 — Independent Aguadilla Analysis:
https://www.3af.fr/global/gene/link.php?doc_link=%2Fdocs%2F2021175110_annex-report-aguadilla-en-18-oct-2021.pdf&fg=1
THE EVIDENTIARY CONCLUSION
The recording documents an unusual observation worthy of investigation. But the available evidence does not independently prove extraordinary speed, underwater travel, or physical splitting.
Conventional explanations remain plausible, while the object's precise identity has not been conclusively established by the evidence reviewed.
The investigation continues.
Evidentiary — Follow the evidence.
Website: https://evidentiarypodcast.com
Newsletter: https://evidentiarypodcast.substack.com - A concealed face. A disguised voice. Official-looking documents promising extraordinary secrets.
In 1988, UFO Cover-Up? Live! introduced viewers to an anonymous source called Falcon. Where did his information come from—and what happens when we follow the paperwork backward?
Investigative journalist and host Lew Austin Hastings examines Paul Bennewitz’s reports near Kirtland Air Force Base, Richard Doty’s disputed role, William Moore’s account of misleading information, the Project Aquarius message, and the alleged Majestic 12 papers.
Through archival audio, historical correspondence, and official records, we separate what was reported, what was claimed, and what the evidence supports.
Who appeared as Falcon on television? Was he the same person Moore described as his private source? And does identifying the messenger authenticate the message?
We close with the Evidentiary Conclusion: what we can establish, what remains disputed, and which missing records could change the findings.
EVIDENTIARY. FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE.
SHOW NOTES & SOURCES
OFFICIAL RECORDS
National Archives — MJ-12 reference report
The Cutler–Twining memorandum, searches for corroborating records, and authenticity concerns. Archival custody does not itself authenticate a document.
https://www.archives.gov/research/military/air-force/ufos#mj12
FBI Vault — Majestic 12
Released records concerning purported MJ-12 material and the assessment recorded in the file.
https://vault.fbi.gov/Majestic%2012
GAO — Comments on Majestic 12 Material (1995)
Agency authenticity assessments and AFOSI’s response concerning a November 1980 message containing “MJ Twelve.”
https://www.gao.gov/assets/154832.pdf
HISTORICAL ACCOUNTS
Robert Hastings — The MJ-12 Affair: Facts, Questions, Comments
His investigation and stated basis for connecting Doty with Falcon. Researcher Robert Hastings is distinct from host Lew Austin Hastings.
https://www.ufohastings.com/articles/the-mj-12-affair-facts-questions-comments
Hastings dossier and correspondence — hosted by MUFON
Includes Kirtland material, Linda Moulton Howe’s declaration, and Doty’s March 1989 rebuttal. Claims remain attributed to their authors.
https://projectaquarius.mufon.com/wp-content/uploads/pcg-bill-moore-files-collection/HASTINGS-G.pdf
William Moore — 1989 MUFON address
Published account in the 1989 MUFON UFO Journal volume. A participant’s retrospective account requires independent corroboration.
https://projectaquarius.mufon.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/January_December_1989.pdf
NICAP — Kirtland AFOSI transcription
Compare specific wording with the scanned enclosure in the Hastings dossier.
https://www.nicap.org/foia_003.htm
ARCHIVAL AUDIO
Excerpts from UFO Cover-Up? Live! (1988) and William Moore’s 1989 MUFON presentation document what speakers said; they do not establish the truth of their claims.
Broadcast source:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sA5GpKcJ3zc
Moore presentation:
https://archive.org/details/bill-moore-1989-mufon
EVIDENCE NOTE
This episode does not authenticate an extraterrestrial recovery program or conclusively identify Falcon. Multiple retellings of the same source are not independent corroboration.
FOLLOW EVIDENTIARY
Follow the show and share this episode with someone who wants to examine the evidence behind the story.
https://evidentiarypodcast.com
Instagram: @evidentiarypodcast
Host: Lew Austin Hastings
Investigative Journalist and Host - In December 1980, American airmen entered an English forest to investigate unusual lights. Their reports—and a senior officer’s recording—became the foundation of one of Britain’s most famous UFO cases.
In “Rendlesham: The Memo, the Tape, and the Lights,” Investigative Journalist and Host Lew Austin Hastings examines early witness statements, Charles Halt’s memo and recording, police records, and explanations involving a meteor, a lighthouse and stars.
Evidentiary’s independent research includes a review of 297 archived pages, a reconstruction of the night sky and responses to our records requests.
EVIDENTIARY CONCLUSION
The records establish that military personnel reported unusual lights. Ordinary explanations have supporting evidence for parts of the case. The material examined does not establish a landed nonhuman craft, an extraordinary radiation source or verified radar confirmation. Questions remain.
SOURCES AND FURTHER READING
The National Archives — UFO research guide:
https://cdn.nationalarchives.gov.uk/documents/aug-2011-research-guide.pdf
Halt’s January 13, 1981 memo — archive image:
https://images.nationalarchives.gov.uk/asset/76305/
DEFE 24/1995/1 — file examined by Evidentiary; includes later submitted accounts and MOD correspondence:
https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C10651781
Released Suffolk Police records — preserved copy:
https://www.ufoscans.com/unusuallights/
Orford Ness lighthouse — Suffolk Heritage Explorer:
https://heritage.suffolk.gov.uk/Monument/MSF22526
Orwell Astronomical Society — historical notes, including the December 1980 fireball:
https://www.oasi.org.uk/Misc/Astro_news.php
IAN RIDPATH’S RESEARCH
These pages present Ridpath’s research and interpretations, distinguished in the episode from official findings.
Tape transcript and recording history:
https://www.ianridpath.com/ufo/halttape.html
Tape analysis:
https://www.ianridpath.com/ufo/halttape-analysis1.html
https://www.ianridpath.com/ufo/halttape-analysis2.html
Early witness statements:
https://www.ianridpath.com/ufo/rendlesham2c.html
Fireball:
https://www.ianridpath.com/ufo/rendlesham1d.html
Lighthouse:
https://www.ianridpath.com/ufo/rendlesham2.html
Stars and other lights:
https://www.ianridpath.com/ufo/rendlesham3.html
Radiation:
https://www.ianridpath.com/ufo/rendlesham4.html
1984 Air Force correspondence:
https://www.ianridpath.com/ufo/rendlesham9.html
RESEARCH LIMITS
Later accounts preserved in government files are not automatically corroborated. Our sky calculation supports broad star positions, not a definitive identification. The original BAA meteor report remains unexamined by Evidentiary. MOD and Suffolk responses concern present records holdings; public redacted copies are pending.
AUDIO AND CREDITS
Field recording: Lieutenant Colonel Charles I. Halt and other personnel, December 1980. Excerpts use this circulating Wikimedia copy:
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Rendelsham.ogg
The recording has gaps and is not an authenticated original master. Its public-domain designation is disputed.
Thanks to Ian Ridpath for research guidance and audio-source information. His permission concerned his hosted version, rather than the Wikimedia copy used here. His assistance does not imply endorsement.
Narration and editorial analysis: Lew Austin Hastings / Evidentiary. Theme music supplied by the host.
Original records, corrections and contact:
https://evidentiarypodcast.com
Evidentiary. Follow the evidence. - Three UAP hearings. What does the public evidence establish?
Lew Austin Hastings examines the 2023–2025 UAP hearings: firsthand observations, source accounts and checkable records.
Testimony is not a verified finding. Program allegations, email removal, performance, retaliation and origin remain separate claims. Proposed requests and interviews remain future work.
AUDIO EXCERPTS AND ATTRIBUTIONS
Episode times: 44:08 edit. Source times: named archives; other playback versions may differ.
05:02–05:19 — Rep. Tim Burchett and Ryan Graves: why Graves came forward.
09:57–10:19 — Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and David Grusch: where to look.
Source: House Oversight hearing, July 26, 2023.
2023 hearing video
Graves 02:07:36.580–02:07:53.550; Ocasio-Cortez/Grusch 01:28:44.300–01:29:06.800 (Wikimedia archive).
11:47–11:57 — Joe Rogan and David Grusch: video viewing versus physical presence.
Source: The Joe Rogan Experience #2560, September 30, 2026.
JRE #2560 video
Archive: JRE archive
Archive in/out: 00:58:59.950–00:59:09.700.
14:40–15:03 — Tim Gallaudet qualifies his explanation as speculation.
17:46–18:07 — Robert Garcia asks Gallaudet, Elizondo, Shellenberger and Gold about origin.
Source: House Oversight joint hearing, November 13, 2024.
2024 hearing video
Archive: 2024 archive
Archive in/out: Gallaudet 01:25:53.780–01:26:16.380; Garcia 01:45:33.100–01:45:53.900.
HEARING RECORDS
2023: Ocasio-Cortez pp. 32–33; biological-material exchange p. 40.
2023 transcript PDF
2024: Gallaudet pp. 9–10, 26; Garcia pp. 33–34; submission pp. 8–9.
2024 transcript PDF
2025: Nuccetelli pp. 6–7; Wiggins pp. 8–9; Borland pp. 12–13, 16; Yemen video pp. 28–29. Printed pages.
2025 transcript PDF
IMMACULATE CONSTELLATION SUBMISSION
PDF pp. 1–2. Submission does not authenticate assertions.
Submission PDF
YEMEN VIDEO
Presented by Rep. Eric Burlison, September 9, 2025. He described an October 30, 2024 MQ-9/Hellfire recording off Yemen. His attribution does not verify impact, ricochet, extraordinary survivability or non-human origin.
Burlison video post
AARO GO FAST ANALYSIS
February 6, 2025 assessment.
AARO analysis PDF
ADDITIONAL BACKGROUND
Graves, Aviation Week Check 6 interview, October 25, 2024:
Graves interview
Grusch, JRE #2065, November 21, 2023:
JRE #2065 video
Navy hazard reports released through FOIA:
Navy hazard reports
Explore Evidentiary: Evidentiary website
Records or tips: info@evidentiarypodcast.com
Follow the evidence. - In November 2004, U.S. Navy aviators operating off the coast of Southern California encountered something they could not readily identify.
Commander David Fravor and Lieutenant Commander Alex Dietrich described an unusual white object over the Pacific Ocean. Personnel aboard the USS Princeton also reported extraordinary radar observations. Years later, the encounter became central to the national conversation about unidentified anomalous phenomena.
But what does the evidence actually establish?
In Episode 2 of Evidentiary, host Lew Austin Hastings investigates the Nimitz encounter, examining firsthand testimony, the Navy's publicly released video, the reported radar observations, and later accounts—including material from Jay Stratton's 2026 book.
We separate firsthand observations from later recollections, distinguish documented facts from unverified claims, and explore the questions that remain unanswered.
The central question isn't simply what the witnesses saw. It's what the available evidence can prove.
SOURCE MATERIAL & FURTHER READING
• David Fravor — Testimony before the U.S. House Oversight Committee, July 26, 2023.
• Alex Dietrich — Public interviews concerning the November 2004 encounter, including CBS News reporting.
• U.S. Department of Defense — Official release of three Navy UAP videos, April 27, 2020.
• Jay Stratton — 2026 published account, considered as a later narrative source rather than original 2004 sensor evidence.
• All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO) — Official UAP reporting and historical assessments: https://www.aaro.mil/
EVIDENTIARY — FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE.
Investigations, research, and episode documentation:
https://evidentiarypodcast.com
Have records, documentation, or firsthand information relevant to an investigation? Contact info@evidentiarypodcast.com.
More Natural Sciences podcasts
Trending Natural Sciences podcasts
About Evidentiary Podcast
Follow the evidence. Hosted by Lew Austin Hastings, Evidentiary investigates UFOs and unidentified anomalous phenomena (UAP) through official records, declassified documents, witness accounts, and critical analysis. Each episode separates documented facts from claims, examines competing explanations, and identifies what remains unknown. Explore the sources and case files at evidentiarypodcast.com. New episodes Mondays.
Podcast websiteListen to Evidentiary Podcast, DarkHorse Podcast and many other podcasts from around the world with the radio.net app

Get the free radio.net app
- Stations and podcasts to bookmark
- Stream via Wi-Fi or Bluetooth
- Supports Carplay & Android Auto
- Many other app features

















