Skip to content
Radio Logo
PodcastsNewsThe Irish Question

The Irish Question

The Irish Question
Latest episode

44 episodes

  • The Irish Question

    The Transition Trap

    11/11/2026 | 29 mins.
    Aisling's StoryWhat happens when a young person struggling with gender dysphoria enters the world of medical transition and later questions the decisions made?In this episode of The Irish Question, Elaine Mullally speaks with Aisling O'Reilly Kane, who shares a deeply personal account of growing up with gender dysphoria, discovering transgender support organisations, and undergoing a double mastectomy and testosterone treatment in 2017.Nine years later, Aisling reflects on the medical decisions, the support and safeguarding she experienced, and the legal and personal complications that followed.The conversation explores the influence of schools and support organisations, the distinction between biological sex and legal gender recognition, and the questions Aisling believes should have been asked before medical intervention.A particularly powerful moment comes when Aisling is asked whether she is happy with her surgery. Her response: "I wish it was not available to me."This is a personal account of one individual's experience, raising important questions about informed consent, safeguarding, education and the long-term consequences of medical transition.Chapters00:00 – Introduction: Meet Aisling01:03 – Childhood and early gender dysphoria03:00 – Fear, identity and the desire to appear male05:00 – Discovering transgender organisations07:14 – Growing up and questioning transition10:47 – Did outside influences contribute to confusion?11:43 – Concerns about safeguarding12:33 – Medical referrals and the transition process14:22 – Double mastectomy and testosterone at 1814:36 – Nine years later: Legal complications16:16 – Gender recognition, employment and safeguarding22:44 – Life after transition and personal reflections24:47 – Gender identity teaching in schools28:15 – What advice would Aisling give teenagers?29:23 – Final thoughts and closingSubscribe to The Irish Question for more conversations exploring the issues affecting Irish society.#TheIrishQuestion #TheTransitionTrap #GenderDysphoria #Detransition #ElaineMullally #Safeguarding #InformedConsent
  • The Irish Question

    Can Ireland Be Saved? with Peadar Tóibín

    09/11/2026 | 1h 20 mins.
    Would Aontú put Simon Harris or Micheál Martin back in government? Would it work with People Before Profit? And what would the party actually do about Ireland’s falling birth rate?
    Aontú leader Peadar Tóibín joins Paul Treyvaud, Elaine Mullally and Nick Delehanty on The Irish Question. Nick makes the case for tax cuts as the panel debates the public-sector pay offer, and Tóibín sets out where he wants performance-linked pay. The conversation turns to the cost of raising a family, with Nick putting a direct question to Tóibín on whether Aontú would reverse access to abortion.
    Tóibín also takes aim at Simon Harris after the Fine Gael ard fheis, explains where Aontú sits on the left–right spectrum, and discusses cutting work permits, a possible pact with Independent Ireland and who he would rule out as a coalition partner.
    00:00 Peadar Tóibín joins The Irish Question
    01:11 Aontú’s polling and what it could mean for seats
    04:08 Public-sector pay rises or tax cuts?
    12:29 Should senior public servants and politicians have performance-linked pay?
    19:18 Unions, the EU visit and government spending
    23:24 Why is Ireland’s birth rate falling?
    30:08 Would Aontú reverse access to abortion?
    37:18 What would a pro-family policy look like?
    41:21 Fine Gael’s ard fheis and the row over the dole
    44:03 Tóibín takes aim at Simon Harris
    52:26 Is Aontú left-wing or right-wing?
    57:35 Immigration, asylum and work permits
    1:03:09 Tóibín on his family and influences
    1:09:01 Would Aontú do a deal with Independent Ireland?
    1:12:46 Paul Murphy, Ruth Coppinger and People Before Profit
    1:13:55 Who would Aontú go into government with?
    1:16:19 Could there be an early general election?
  • The Irish Question

    What are Irish Schools Teaching?

    07/11/2026 | 30 mins.
    Unpacking Woke Ideology in Education with Kelly HenriquesA deep dive into how curriculum changes are shaping our children's futures.In this episode, Elaine Mullally sits down with Kelly Henriques to discuss the alarming presence of woke ideology in educational systems, particularly in Ireland. Their conversation highlights how educational reforms are shaping not just the curriculum, but the very values and beliefs of future generations.The Roots of Woke Ideology in EducationKelly reflects on her journey into this topic, pinpointing the junior cycle SPHE specification as a catalyst for her growing concern. "I wasn't really paying attention to what was happening in schools until I read that specification," she admits. This specification, she believes, is a precursor to a much larger agenda at play.Kelly argues that the push for gender ideology in schools is just a symptom of a broader ideological overhaul. "These theories bled out of the academy and were normalized in society, leading to division and chaos. We are witnessing the same thing happen here," she asserts. The Shift in Educational PurposeElaine and Kelly discuss the fundamental changes in education since 2019, which Kelly believes have altered the very purpose of schooling. Instead of fostering knowledge, the aim has shifted towards social transformation. "They want a revolution. It's really about social transformation more than it is about education in and of itself," Kelly explains.This transformation, according to Kelly, is not only about indoctrinating children but also about creating a generation that acts as "agents of change" in society. The Role of Teachers and CurriculumThe conversation turns to the role of educators in this shift. Kelly points out that many experienced teachers are leaving the profession due to dissatisfaction with the new curriculum, while younger teachers are being trained under these new ideological frameworks. "Whoever has control of the curriculum has control of the minds of the youth," Kelly states, emphasizing the broader implications of these changes on future society.Policie Enforcing ChangeElaine and Kelly address the policies that enforce these educational changes, such as the B Canalta policy and the well-being framework. These frameworks obligate schools to comply with Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, which Kelly argues often exclude dissenting views. The Content Exposed to ChildrenFinally, they discuss the content children are being exposed to and the age at which these ideas are introduced. Kelly stresses that the issue is not merely about discussing topics like gender or racism but rather the ideological lens through which these subjects are taught. "It's the way that they're teaching that becomes the issue," she notes.This insightful conversation sheds light on an urgent topic that affects us all, regardless of whether we have children in the education system. It prompts a reflection on how we can engage with these changes and advocate for a more balanced approach to education.For more insights and a deeper dive into the conversation, listen to the full episode.
  • The Irish Question

    Poland Crisis Continues

    05/11/2026 | 33 mins.
    Crisis in Poland: Voices from the GroundInsights on the escalating political turmoil in Poland from activistsThe situation in Poland is dire, with ongoing protests and a government that seems increasingly desperate. Anna Krukowska and Viktor Sudnik joins Elaine Mullally to unpack the current crisis.The Protests ContinueAnna emphasizes the resilience of the Polish people, noting the ongoing protests outside the Constitutional Tribunal. "Unfortunately, nothing seems like the government is looking for any sort of de-escalation. The protest keeps on going, with more and more people joining every day," she shares. This growing unrest is a response to what many see as a government coup, with the ruling party scrambling to secure power before the upcoming elections.A Government in CrisisBoth Anna and Viktor express concern over the government's tactics as they foresee losing control in the next elections. "They know they are losing the elections," Anna states, highlighting the urgency of the current protests. Viktor adds, "The Prime Minister started fighting for his life because he knows he's going to jail for a coup d'état." The fear is palpable as they discuss how the government is consolidating power, undermining key institutions like the Constitutional Tribunal, and stifling dissent.Media SilenceA concerning aspect of this crisis is the lack of coverage in mainstream media. "There's very little to practically zero reporting from mainstream media on this," Elaine notes. Anna points out that the government has taken control of the media landscape, leaving independent outlets to bear the burden of reporting the truth.The Future of Democracy in PolandAs the conversation unfolds, the looming question remains: how will this end? Viktor warns, "We cannot allow it to happen. We will be there every day, peacefully protesting, but still making our voices heard." Both guests are committed to holding those in power accountable, stating, "Once the government changes, we will prosecute them with the full extent of the law."The situation in Poland is evolving rapidly, but the determination of its citizens remains strong. The protests are not just about the present but about safeguarding the future of democracy in Poland.Stay informed on this critical issue as we continue to follow the developments in Poland.
  • The Irish Question

    Why is Ireland So Woke?

    03/11/2026 | 1h 6 mins.
    Why is Ireland so Woke? would Fine Gael moving to the centre-right actually change anything?
    Former Fine Gael councillor and dentist Keith Redmond joins Paul Treyvaud, Elaine Mullally and Nick Delehanty for a lively debate about Simon Harris, the direction of Irish politics and the growing role of the State.
    Keith and Elaine clash over public-sector strikes: do frontline workers deserve better pay, or should reform come before another across-the-board increase? The panel also discusses pressure on small businesses, media coverage of crimes involving asylum seekers, and demands for clearer crime statistics.
    Plus: Community Notes and the fact-checkers, Simon Harris’s call for scrutiny of public spending, funding for advocacy NGOs, and what happened to Benefacts—the organisation that tracked Ireland’s nonprofit sector.
    Finally, the panel challenges the framing of the “manosphere” as a public-health issue, debates Mary McAleese’s comments on infant baptism, and asks whether a smaller State could deliver better outcomes.
    Join the debate in the comments, subscribe, and share the episode.
    TIMESTAMPS
    00:00 Welcome and last week’s audience milestone
    01:08 Introducing guest Keith Redmond
    01:45 Simon Harris under pressure: polls and party tensions
    08:40 Fine Gael’s centre-right motion: real change or political spin?
    14:08 Leadership, paternity leave and political accountability
    16:40 Public-sector strikes: the case for better pay
    18:39 Keith pushes back: spending, staffing and affordability
    21:39 Small businesses, employment costs and the tax burden
    24:54 Frontline workers versus across-the-board pay rises
    28:08 Tralee, IPAS and changing media coverage
    34:01 The debate over crime statistics and country of origin
    39:25 Community Notes, fact-checkers and Harris’s spending pledge
    42:53 NGO funding, political advisers and accountability
    49:45 What happened to Benefacts—and could it return?
    51:58 The manosphere: public-health issue or an attack on masculinity?
    59:40 Anakin Skywalker and young men online
    1:00:46 Elaine’s Poland mini-podcast
    1:01:10 Mary McAleese, baptism and parents’ rights
    1:04:47 Nick’s closing argument for a smaller State
    1:05:37 Final thoughts and farewell
    #TheIrishQuestion #IrishPolitics #SimonHarris #FineGael #KeithRedmond
More News podcasts
About The Irish Question
We talk about the questions and topics that everyone is thinking about but most are afraid to say out loud. We don't hold back. We are not told what we can and can't say. You won't agree with everything we say, but we guarantee you the truth, honesty and a very unique podcast. SIgn up to all our social media platforms so we can build a group of like minded people
Podcast website

Listen to The Irish Question, The Rest Is Politics: US and many other podcasts from around the world with the radio.net app

Get the free radio.net app

  • Stations and podcasts to bookmark
  • Stream via Wi-Fi or Bluetooth
  • Supports Carplay & Android Auto
  • Many other app features