Ryan O’Hara, co-owner of Pizza Grace and Big Spoon Creamery in Birmingham, Alabama, joins PEEL: A PMQ Pizza Podcast to discuss how a sourdough-focused pizzeria earned a MICHELIN Bib Gourmand just months after changing ownership. Alongside his wife, Geri-Martha, O’Hara acquired Pizza Grace in 2025, preserving its naturally fermented foundation while reimagining nearly every other aspect of the business.
In this episode, O’Hara shares the story behind Frank, Pizza Grace’s 23-year-old sourdough starter, and explains why natural fermentation continues to resonate with both operators and consumers. He discusses lessons learned while working under acclaimed chef Frank Stitt, the importance of ingredient quality and restraint, and how seasonal pizzas featuring unexpected combinations like prosciutto, pistachio and strawberry jam come to life. O’Hara also reflects on the challenges of sudden growth following Pizza Grace’s MICHELIN recognition, building a culture where “it’s cool to care,” and why Birmingham has become one of the South’s most exciting food destinations.