In this episode of the Preaching Coach Podcast, Dr. David L. Allen reflects on excerpts from an anonymous 1885 article, “Modern Homiletics,” from the Southern Presbyterian Review, exploring whether preachers’ textbook ideals of sermons actually serve congregations. The article argues that modern sermon forms owe much to Greek rhetoric and Aristotle rather than New Testament preaching, and warns that polished, “fine” sermons can become empty displays of verbosity with little practical effect. True preaching, it contends, aims at specific, present impact on listeners, even if it breaks homiletical rules. The piece highlights D.L. Moody as an example of effectiveness without textbook form, urging preachers not to depend too much on methods apart from the Holy Spirit.