Discussions about the science of nutrition, dietetics and health. The podcast that educates through nuanced conversations, exploring evidence and cultivating cr...
#555: What Should the Dietary Guidelines Say? – Prof. Christopher Gardner
Every five years, the U.S. Dietary Guidelines are updated based on the latest scientific evidence to help shape national nutrition recommendations. A panel of experts was assembled to review the existing research, evaluate new findings, and provide recommendations that will inform the next edition of the guidelines. One of the committee members involved in this process is Professor Christopher Gardner, a leading nutrition scientist at Stanford University, who joins us to share key insights from the committee’s work. In this discussion, Professor Gardner provides an inside look into how the committee evaluated dietary patterns, the role of plant-based proteins, and the ongoing debate surrounding ultra-processed foods. He explains the rigorous process of reviewing scientific literature, the challenges in translating research into policy, and the critical role of health equity in shaping the recommendations. By exploring these themes, this episode aims to provide clarity on the scientific foundation behind the upcoming dietary guidelines. Whether you’re a nutrition professional, researcher, or someone interested in how dietary recommendations are formed, this conversation sheds light on the key discussions shaping the future of nutrition policy. Timestamps [03:38] Interview begins [07:18] The rigorous process behind formulating dietary guidelines [12:10] Key questions addressed and major findings from the report [25:41] Identifying nutrients of concern and refining dietary patterns [33:39] The importance of health equity in dietary recommendations [36:04] Reassessing dairy’s role in different population groups [41:05] Shifting the focus towards plant-based protein sources [47:52] The debate on ultra-processed foods and public health implications [58:24] Key Ideas segment (Premium-only) Related Resources Enroll in the next cohort of our Applied Nutrition Literacy course Subscribe to Sigma Nutrition Premium Join the Sigma email newsletter for free Scientific Report of the 2025 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee Previous episode with Prof. Gardner: Episode 223
--------
59:29
#554: Crucial Ideas for Understanding Nutrition Science
Understanding the complexities of diet-disease relationships requires a nuanced approach to nutritional science. Unlike other scientific disciplines, nutrition research often grapples with the inherent challenges of studying dietary patterns and nutrient intakes in free-living populations over long periods. The cumulative effects of dietary exposures, combined with the necessity to control for confounding factors such as total energy intake and population-specific dietary habits, highlight the need for rigorous study designs and careful interpretation of findings. Despite their utility, these methods are often misunderstood or misrepresented in public discourse. Addressing these misunderstandings requires a clear communication of key principles underpinning nutritional science, including the role of cumulative exposure, the importance of contextualizing absolute and relative risks, and the necessity of evaluating the long-term effects of dietary patterns. This episode aims to provide a comprehensive overview of these essential ideas, equipping readers with the tools to critically appraise the evidence and engage meaningfully with the ongoing conversation around nutrition research. Timestamps [03:26] Understanding nutrition science: core concepts [06:01] Standards of proof in nutrition research [19:39] Unique challenges in nutrition research [26:30] High vs. low exposure in nutrition studies [34:34] Challenges in nutrition randomized control trials [39:29] Understanding null by design in nutrition trials [41:58] The importance of temporal relationships in diet and disease [43:55] Relative risk vs. absolute risk [57:16] The role of substitution and adjustment in nutrition studies Related Resources Enroll in the next cohort of our Applied Nutrition Literacy course Join the Sigma email newsletter for free Subscribe to Sigma Nutrition Premium Episodes referenced: 531: Correlation, Causation & Cliché 478: Exposures in Nutrition – Why They’re Crucial to Understand 511: Null By Design – When “No Effect” Doesn’t Mean No Effect 378: Nutritional Epidemiology 472: Compared To What? – Understanding Food Substitution Analysis & Adjustment Models
--------
1:13:12
#553: Healthy Habits for Fertility and Reproductive Health – Marjorie Nolan Cohn, RD
This episode focuses on the intersection of nutrition, lifestyle, and women’s health, with a particular emphasis on managing complex conditions such as PCOS, endometriosis, and premenstrual dysphoric disorder (PMDD). Registered dietitian Marjorie Nolan Cohn shares insights from over two decades of clinical practice, highlighting the importance of addressing foundational health behaviors—such as adequate sleep, hydration, and nutrient-dense dietary patterns—before introducing targeted interventions like supplementation. Marjorie explores the nuanced relationship between body weight, metabolic health, and fertility, while addressing misconceptions around weight loss as a primary health goal. The episode examines the role of long-term, individualized care in improving symptoms and outcomes for women experiencing significant menstrual-related challenges. Practical considerations for practitioners, including strategies to build trust, identify key barriers, and provide holistic support, are outlined alongside the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration to improve care quality. Marjorie Nolan Cohn is a registered dietitian with a Masters Degree in Food and Nutrition Science from the Indiana University of Pennsylvania. She is the Clinical Director of Berry Street, a company providing virtual in-network nutritional counseling to people across the US. Timestamps [04:32] Beginning of the interview [08:39] The role of nutrition in fertility [13:40] Understanding PCOS and endometriosis [16:28] Barriers to accurate women’s health diagnoses [19:03] Exploring diet and lifestyle strategies [23:28] Addressing challenges in women’s health and nutrition [39:01] Closing remarks and final takeaways Related Resources Join the Sigma email newsletter for free Subscribe to Sigma Nutrition Premium Enroll in the next cohort of our Applied Nutrition Literacy course Guest website: Berry Street
--------
40:58
#552: Diet & Sleep Interactions – Marie-Pierre St. Onge, PhD
Over the past couple of decades, renowned researcher Dr. Marie-Pierre St-Onge has uncovered fascinating links between how we sleep and what we eat, revealing how these two lifestyle factors influence energy balance, cardiovascular health, and metabolic function. In this episode we’ll explore Dr. St-Onge’s findings on sleep regularity and its association with reduced mortality risk, providing actionable insights for optimizing your lifestyle. With a focus on combining rigorous methodologies and controlled dietary interventions, her research sheds light on the complex mechanisms connecting sleep, diet, and metabolic health. Timestamps: [03:39] Dr. St-onge's academic journey and evolution of her research interests [07:03] Overcoming methodological challenges in sleep and nutrition research [10:20] The importance of sleep regularity for health [15:44] Exploring the bidirectional connection between diet and sleep [23:40] Unpacking the mechanisms linking diet to sleep quality [37:33] Practical recommendations for optimizing sleep and diet Links: Join the Sigma email newsletter for free Subscribe to Sigma Nutrition Premium Enroll in the next cohort of our Applied Nutrition Literacy course Article: How Sleep & Nutrition Interact – Alan Flanagan, PhD Go to episode page
--------
41:04
Multivitamin Nihilism: Is it Actually Worthless to Supplement? (SNP37)
Multivitamin and multimineral supplements have long been a topic of both scientific inquiry and public debate. While they are often marketed as convenient solutions for achieving nutritional adequacy, their true value remains contentious. Are these supplements essential insurance policies against nutrient deficiencies, or are they merely expensive placebos? Importantly, how should we weigh their potential benefits against the lack of robust evidence for long-term health outcomes such as reduced mortality or chronic disease risk? These questions demand a nuanced exploration, grounded in the context of specific populations and individual needs. Ultimately, the role of multivitamin supplements cannot be assessed in isolation but must be viewed through the lens of context and specificity. How do we balance the biological plausibility of benefits against the variability of individual diets, the presence of fortification policies, and the challenges of achieving dietary adequacy in certain life stages? These considerations invite a more thoughtful and less binary discussion about whether, when, and for whom multivitamins are a worthwhile addition to the diet. Timestamps [00:22] The debate on multivitamins: worthless or beneficial? [00:53] Rationale behind multivitamin use [04:04] Modern nutritional adequacy and multivitamins [07:10] Evidence supporting multivitamin use [23:39] Long-term health outcomes and multivitamins [41:43] Cognitive outcomes [50:18] Pregnancy and multivitamin use Related Resources Join the Sigma email newsletter for free Subscribe to Sigma Nutrition Premium Enroll in the next cohort of our Applied Nutrition Literacy course Shaun Ward Article: Multivitamin Madness: There’s More to Life than Death Studies mentioned: MacPherson et al., 2013 meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials Jenkins et al., 2021 meta-analysis COSMOS trial – Vyas et al., 2024 analysis of three substudies Loftfield et al., 2024 – Multivitamin Use and Mortality in 3 Cohorts Blumberg et al., 2017 nutritional adequacy paper
Discussions about the science of nutrition, dietetics and health. The podcast that educates through nuanced conversations, exploring evidence and cultivating critical thinking. Hosted by Danny Lennon.