1228 episodes
- E1231: Google is testing removing AI Mode from Google Search, even though people predicted AI Mode would be the default search experience by now.
And there's a possible reason: AI search isn't monetizing nearly as well as traditional search.
I cover Google's latest AI Mode tests, a study examining why ChatGPT ads aren't delivering returns for advertisers, and what this means for SEO and digital marketing.
Here's what I cover:
- Google tests removing AI Mode: Search Engine Roundtable reports that Google is testing removing the AI Mode tab from search results, the AI Mode button from its homepage, and the "Ask Anything" follow-up box from AI Overviews.
- Why Google might be testing this: AI Mode generates less advertising revenue than traditional Google Search. Could monetization explain these experiments?
- Google's Q3 2026 earnings: Alphabet's revenue and advertising revenue missed Wall Street expectations, net income fell 25% year over year, and shares dropped approximately 10% in after-hours trading.
- A study of ChatGPT advertising: Research analyzed nearly 1,900 online stores representing $16 billion in annual sales across 60 weeks of data.
- ChatGPT ads versus Google Ads: According to the study, a paid ChatGPT visit generated $0.89 in revenue compared with $2.45 for a paid Google Search visit.
- Why ChatGPT ads are overpriced: The researchers estimated that a ChatGPT ad click was worth approximately $0.26 at comparable paid-search returns, despite one major advertiser paying $1.72 per click.
- OpenAI's monetization problem: The study examines the gap between current advertising revenue per free ChatGPT user and OpenAI's projected advertising revenue by 2030.
- Google admits AI Mode monetizes less: Google's Chief Business Officer, Philipp Schindler, has acknowledged that AI Mode's growing query volume affects monetization because it generates less advertising revenue than traditional search.
- What happened to Google's AI search announcements? I revisit Google I/O's May announcements, the predictions that traditional search results would disappear, and how AI features haven't materialized as expected.
- Why traditional SEO still matters: AI search engines still need to retrieve information, identify relevant sources, and recommend businesses, products, and services.
- What you should actually do as an SEO: Stop reacting to every prediction that SEO is dead. Keep targeting high-intent keywords, building conversion-focused landing pages, strengthening your website's authority, and earning backlinks.
The takeaway:
These experiments, combined with the challenges of monetizing AI search, are a reminder that predictions about the future of search aren't guarantees.
People have been predicting the death of SEO for years. Meanwhile, businesses continue generating customers through search.
The fundamentals of SEO that worked 10 and 15 years ago still matter today.
Don't let predictions about AI distract you from implementing the SEO strategies that get sales.
⭐️ Google Tests Dropping AI Mode From Search Bar & Ask Anything - https://www.seroundtable.com/google-dropping-ai-mode-again-42534.html
⭐️ Google: Ads In AI Mode Earning Less Than Traditional Search Ads - https://www.seroundtable.com/google-ai-mode-ads-earn-less-42417.html
⭐️ Rand Fishkin sharing Christian Schulze's study on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/posts/randfishkin_ive-been-asking-folks-about-their-experiences-share-7523123404594536448-CzR2/
⭐️ Ep 1053 - The Era of 10 Blue Links Is Over (Google I/O Search + May 2026 Core Update) - https://youtu.be/eD6sNhLHM0I
💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/
00:00 AI Mode Default Hype
00:16 Google Tests Removing AI Mode
01:28 Monetization Concerns
02:10 ChatGPT Ads Study
03:14 Why ChatGPT Ads Underperform
04:39 AI Search Monetization Reality
04:59 Don't Panic SEO Mindset
06:06 Google IO Panic Recap
06:36 What Still Wins in Search
07:09 Wrap Up The Best SEO
The Edward Show. Your daily search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/
#searchengineoptimization #seo #generativeengineoptimization #digitalmarketing - E1230: What were the top SEOs at Chiang Mai SEO 2026 talking about when they weren't on stage?
This episode brings the conference to you!
Eight guests join from Chiang Mai to share what they learned, what they heard in private conversations, and which SEO experiments they're going to test next.
We discuss Google rankings, AI search, link building, exact-match domains, local SEO, and the tactics people were swapping at dinners and after-parties. Some are strategies the guests are already using. Others are ideas they want to test.
In this episode:
- Why ranking first in Google does not guarantee visibility in AI Overviews, and whether GEO is different from SEO.
- Why SEOs are building exact-match domains (EMDs), directories, and satellite websites instead of relying on one site.
- How an AI agent bought 400 domains after receiving rules for price, relevance, and availability.
- Why one black-hat SEO bought 4,500 domains knowing they might all get taken down.
- How SEOs are using third-party listicles, awards, directories, and brand mentions to influence AI recommendations.
- How Kalin uses a network of 30,000 websites to publish unlinked brand mentions designed to influence AI search results.
- Whether your position in a listicle determines if ChatGPT cites or recommends you.
- An experiment involving rankings in smaller countries to influence more competitive markets.
- What Common Crawl and harmonic centrality have to do with AI training data and website discovery.
- How backlinks may matter differently for traditional Google search and AI-generated answers.
- Changes people are testing in local SEO, including Google Business Profiles, map rankings, and chamber of commerce links.
- A forum schema tactic discussed at the conference and why short-term SEO tests need scrutiny.
- How AI agents are reducing administrative work and letting SEOs launch and test more websites.
- What ChatGPT business profile data shows about linked mentions, and what it leaves out.
- Why some teams are testing what happens when they block ChatGPT, Claude, and Common Crawl bots.
- How fabricated awards and supporting websites can create misleading evidence for AI systems.
- When churn-and-burn SEO can make money, and why sustainable businesses need a different strategy.
This is a look at what experienced SEOs are doing, testing, and questioning as Google and AI search change. If you couldn't make it to Chiang Mai, this is your chance to hear their conversations.
⭐️ Chiang Mai SEO Conference - https://chiangmaiseoconference.com/
⭐️ David Quaid on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/davidquaid/
⭐️ Kasra Dash on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/kasra-dash/
⭐️ Kyle Roof on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/kyle-roof-seo/
⭐️ Jabez Reuben on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/jabezreuben/
⭐️ Yash Singh on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/yash-singh-35844b3b1/
⭐️ Dennis Yu on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/dennisyu/
⭐️ Felix Norton on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/felixwnorton/
⭐️ Kalin Karakehayov on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/karakehayov/
💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/
00:00 Chiang Mai SEO Kickoff
00:42 Conference Vibes and Networking
02:09 Biggest Takeaways Brand and AEO
03:19 Is GEO Different From SEO
04:37 David Returns to Conferences
07:44 Schema Hacks and Fast Rankings
09:17 Black Hat Tactics Revealed
11:58 Kyle Roof Joins
15:23 AI Productivity Workflows
17:09 Behind the Scenes Conference Talk
18:44 Jabez on Planning and Speakers
22:19 Agentic Web and Traffic Surge
27:28 Real Time SEO Changes and GBP
30:17 Seeding LLMs via Small Markets
32:15 Geographic SEO Cornerstones
33:22 Foreign Language LLM Reality
34:22 Scaling EMD Satellite Networks
36:25 Conference Takeaways Testing Myths
39:23 AI Visibility B2B vs B2C
40:23 Agents Demand Real Facts
44:17 New Guest Yash Local SEO
47:23 ChatGPT Business Profiles
50:07 Luxury Villa SEO Playbook
52:41 Affiliate Sites Hyper Personalization
56:51 Fake Claims Corroboration
01:00:34 Links Common Crawl Centrality
01:07:31 Dennis Yu on Knowledge Panels
01:14:31 Knowledge Becomes Free
01:15:49 Conference Takeaways 10x
01:16:58 Black Hat Lessons
01:18:50 SEO As Competition
01:22:05 Minimum Viable Pages
01:25:11 SEO Veteran Origins
01:27:45 Decision Engine Reputation
01:31:37 Omnipresent SEO Mix
01:35:35 Agency Future Value
01:40:32 Churn Burn Reality
01:47:05 Testing And Exposing Tactics
01:50:45 GigaLinks Explained
01:55:28 Mentions Versus Penalties
01:59:45 Final Thanks And Wrap
The Edward Show. Your daily search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/
#searchengineoptimization #seo #generativeengineoptimization #answerengineoptimization - E1229: Google's Gary Illyes says you should use AI. He also says AI features in Google Search use the same processes as traditional results. In other words, AI Search is still SEO.
At Google's Search Central Live conference in Barcelona, Google employees discussed AI-generated content, search quality, Merchant Center, and AI slop.
I break down what Google said and what it means for SEO.
Here's what I cover:
1. Gary Illyes: Use AI, but use it responsibly.
Gary closed the conference with three messages:
- Use AI to speed up content, website, and customer management workflows.
- Verify AI output. AI hallucinates, and inaccurate content adds to low-quality pages online.
- AI on Google is just SEO. Google's AI Search features rely on the same infrastructure as traditional results.
He also questioned whether we need a new acronym for AI Search.
2. How companies get cited in AI Search.
I share the story of an industry leader who wanted more AI recommendations.
- He used Peec AI to find third-party listicles frequently cited for high-intent prompts.
- He paid the authors to place his company at the top.
- Those articles were already relevant and easy for AI search systems to retrieve.
- The tactic differs from traditional SEO, but relevance and discoverability still matter.
3. Google's conversational attributes for ecommerce.
Google software engineer Alex Jansen discussed conversational attributes in Google Merchant Center: flexible product details that AI systems use to answer shopping questions.
These include:
- Product Q&As, such as capacity and safety features.
- Documentation links, including manuals and assembly guides.
- Related products and product group titles.
- Variants such as sizes, colors, and memory configurations.
- Product popularity rankings.
I explain why this information also belongs on your website, and how I prefer scannable text over hiding everything in accordions.
4. Google's warning about low-quality AI content.
Google search quality analyst Dan Nguyen discussed how AI is flooding the internet with low-quality pages.
- Google cares about quality, not whether a human or AI wrote the content.
- Original reviews include proprietary metrics, firsthand photos, and research.
- Generic content that adds nothing new gives users little reason to choose your page.
- I discuss the November 2026 Google core update and speculation about AI-generated content.
5. Google Discover, user feedback, and AI slop.
Google Discover trust and safety analyst Eric Murillo said AI slop is increasing and user feedback informs new spam filters.
I discuss:
- Why dissatisfied searchers matter.
- Returning to Google after clicking an unhelpful result.
- Users avoiding brands after a bad experience.
- Google's leaked statement: "We don't understand content. We fake it."
- Behavioral data and search quality.
- How page titles, URLs, H1s, and opening sentences remain important for relevance.
Bottom line: Google encourages AI use, but wants useful, accurate content. AI Search doesn't make SEO obsolete.
⭐️ We Are ROAST write up - https://weareroast.com/news/google-search-central-live-deep-dive-barcelona-day-3-recap/
⭐️ How to use conversational attributes - https://support.google.com/merchants/answer/17085370
💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/
00:00 Google Says Use AI
00:46 Use AI Responsibly
01:00 AI Search Is SEO
01:35 Influencing AI Citations
02:33 Conversational Attributes
04:14 Flood Of Low Quality Content
04:42 Core Update And AI Content
05:28 Discover And User Feedback
07:38 Proper SEO
09:09 Wrap Up And Thanks
The Edward Show. Your daily search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/
#searchengineoptimization #seo #generativeengineoptimization #answerengineoptimization - E1228: Third-party rank trackers are becoming less reliable. Google is making it harder for them to collect accurate rankings, and the result can be dramatic ranking drops that don't match what Google Search Console shows.
I show you the rank tracker we built for the company I'm funding, explain why we built it, and walk through how to make your own using Google Search Console, BigQuery, and DataForSEO.
The YouTube version includes screenshots of our dashboard. I've replaced the company name, keywords, and URLs to keep the business private, but the dashboard layout and data presentation reflect the tool we use.
Here's what I cover:
- Why third-party rank trackers can show sudden ranking losses even when Google Search Console shows stable or improving performance.
- How Google's efforts to disrupt automated SERP collection can cause misleading rank tracking data and bad SEO decisions.
- Why Google Search Console is the data source I trust for tracking our own search performance.
- Why we back up Google Search Console data to BigQuery instead of relying on just Search Console.
- How to build a private rank tracking dashboard from that data, without writing the code yourself.
- Why we track only keywords we're deliberately targeting instead of every query our site appears for.
- How our dashboard shows ranking trends across different date ranges, with daily, weekly, and monthly views.
- How we use DataForSEO's clickstream-based search volume estimates to sort keywords by potential opportunity.
- Why we also display clicks to compare our traffic against estimated search volume.
- How we organize target keywords using labels for hub pages, subfolders, search intent, and other categories.
- What appears on each keyword's detail page: current position, movement over the selected period, period average, search volume, labels, and historical rankings.
- How a journal of SEO changes can explain ranking movements and guide page improvements.
- Why I consider rankings a more useful weekly SEO performance measure than revenue, which depends on pricing, product, conversion rate, support, and other factors.
- Why a simple dashboard that shows the metrics you act on is better than one cluttered with data.
You can use the screenshots from this episode as a reference when building your own dashboard. I also explain what we leave out and why.
The goal is to know whether the SEO changes you make are improving rankings for the keywords that matter to your business, without making decisions based on unreliable third-party data or distracting noise.
⭐️ Screenshots and episode transcript: https://edwardsturm.com/articles/build-your-own-rank-tracker/
⭐️ Clickstream Data API (DataForSEO) - https://dataforseo.com/pricing/keywords-data/clickstream-api-pricing
⭐️ Export GSC Data to BigQuery - https://support.google.com/webmasters/topic/12917674?hl=en&ref_topic=9354552&sjid=9661028753422321451-NA
💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/
00:00 Why Build Your Own Tracker
00:38 Rank Trackers Are Breaking
01:43 BigQuery Source Of Truth
02:19 Rankings Not Revenue
03:39 Keyword Targeting Basics
05:35 Dashboard Filters And Labels
07:02 Keyword Detail And SEO Journal
08:50 Keep It Minimal And Copy
11:37 Podcast Outro And Thanks
The Edward Show. Your daily search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/
#searchengineoptimization #seo #martech #performancemarketing ChatGPT vs Claude vs Gemini for SEO: We Tested All 3 on Nike's Site (One Was Terrible)
13/11/2026 | 36 mins.E1227: Can ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini replace an SEO agency? Harpreet Singh shares his screen to test all three AI tools on the same Nike website page - and show why following their SEO advice blindly can waste hours.
We gave ChatGPT, Claude, and Google Gemini Nike Canada's men's running shoes category page and the same prompt: "Give me SEO, AEO, and GEO recommendations for this page. Prioritize them based on impact."
All three produced detailed audits. But they disagreed on what mattered most, overlooked important issues, and repeatedly treated low-impact changes as urgent.
We cover:
- What ChatGPT got right about product comparisons, category navigation, and internal linking.
- Why ChatGPT prioritized adding FAQs ahead of improving the page title - and why we disagreed.
- How vague recommendations to "validate" crawlability and indexation can send beginners down hours-long rabbit holes.
- What Claude spotted that ChatGPT missed: UK language signals on Nike's Canadian page, including "trainers" in the title and an en-GB language setting.
- Why Claude flagged a major product discovery concern: 45 products listed on the page, but only 24 found in the HTML, with others loaded through JavaScript.
- How footer links to the UK site created another potential problem for Canadian shoppers.
- Where Claude still went wrong with FAQ markup and unsupported claims about AI citations.
- Why structured data may improve search appearance and click-through rates without fixing weak rankings.
- How Gemini ranked meta description keyword changes and removing meta keywords among its top SEO recommendations.
- Why adding FAQ schema isn't a proven shortcut to ranking in Google AI Overviews or being cited by AI tools.
- How years of repeated SEO advice can become misleading recommendations from AI systems.
- Which changes deserve attention first: titles, headings, search intent, localization, crawlable product links, and relevant internal links.
- Why looking at one URL without understanding the rest of the website limits any AI audit.
- Why tracking positions for the keywords you're actively targeting can be more useful than a crowded SEO reporting dashboard.
- How to apply the 80/20 rule so AI gives you a few high-impact recommendations instead of an overwhelming checklist.
We also share a practical way to use AI for SEO audits:
1. Crawl your site with Screaming Frog SEO Spider. The free version covers up to 500 URLs.
2. Open the Issues tab and export the findings.
3. Upload the export to Claude, along with this episode's transcript.
AI can speed up SEO work, but you still need to judge whether its advice is accurate, relevant, and worth implementing.
⭐️ Episode Transcript - https://edwardsturm.com/wp-content/uploads/Ep-1227_Harpreet-Singh_ChatGPT-vs-Claude-vs-Gemini-for-SEO-We-Tested-All-3-on-Nikes-Site-One-Was-Terrible.txt
⭐️ Harpreet Singh's Personal Site - https://harpsdigital.com
⭐️ Harpreet on X - https://x.com/harpreetchatha_
⭐️ Harpreet's Newsletter - https://seoespresso.com
⭐️ Harpreet on LinkedIn - https://linkedin.com/in/harpreetsingh8/
⭐️ Harpreet on TikTok - https://tiktok.com/@seoharp
⭐️ Harpreet on YouTube - https://youtube.com/@seoharp
💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/
00:00 AI SEO Hype Check
01:01 Testing Three LLMs
02:41 ChatGPT Priorities Review
03:55 UX vs SEO Impact
05:00 Internal Links Done Right
06:59 Crawl Checks Rabbit Holes
09:50 FAQ Advice Is Outdated
12:45 Metadata Should Come First
14:05 Localization and Hreflang
18:00 Too Many Low Value Tips
19:41 Measuring SEO Success Now
20:27 SEO Success Metrics
21:02 ChatGPT Audit Gaps
22:17 Claude High Impact Fixes
24:20 Schema Versus Rankings
25:35 Bad FAQ Schema Advice
28:43 Gemini Recommendations Review
30:05 Pareto Prompting Framework
32:19 Screaming Frog Plus LLMs
34:17 AI Hype And SEO Noise
35:43 Wrap Up And Where To Follow
The Edward Show. Your daily search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/
#searchengineoptimization #seo #ecommerce #aiseo
More Business podcasts
Trending Business podcasts
About The Edward Show
Daily SEO advice, hacks, and interviews with some of the top voices in search engine optimization, as well as sit-downs with many undiscovered talents.
Podcast websiteListen to The Edward Show, Informed Decisions: Ireland's Independent Retirement Planning Podcast and many other podcasts from around the world with the radio.net app

Get the free radio.net app
- Stations and podcasts to bookmark
- Stream via Wi-Fi or Bluetooth
- Supports Carplay & Android Auto
- Many other app features
The Edward Show: Podcasts in Family






































